Milstein's
plan was to use the existing infrastructure and charter as a
springboard to create a private bank for the wealthy tri-state
population. After his election as chairman, Milstein recruited private
banking and family office veteran William Fuhs to be president and CEO
of the newly established New York Private Bank & Trust. Hannah Shaw
Grove, executive editor of
Private Wealth, speaks with Bill at the bank's mid-town offices.
Grove: You
received your Federal trust powers in 2006, a relatively recent time
frame for the old-world business of private banking. What was Howard
Milstein hoping to accomplish?
Fuhs: Howard
gave me two mandates when I joined the bank in early 2004. The first
was to deliver the high-touch, extremely attentive and customized
service that most private banks have long since abandoned. The second
was to avoid conflicts of interests with our clients.
In the
past, it has not always been clear if a private bank's advice or
services to their clients is conflicted. Frequently banks, acting as
trustee, have also been the money manager. The conflict arises when
they manage the money poorly for extended periods of time. If it was
outside a trust they would be fired. As a trustee they have a fiduciary
responsibility to act only in the best interest of their clients.
Should they fire themselves as the money manager? Have you ever heard
of a private bank doing that?
To fulfill Howard's mandate to
not have our interests conflict with those of our clients, we have
chosen not to manage equities. Instead, we select investment managers
for our clients, and if or when appropriate, we replace them.
Grove: Are those mandates still important operating tenets of the bank?
Fuhs: Absolutely.
We do all the things you'd expect a private bank to do-give advice, act
as a trustee or executor, negotiate lower investment minimums for our
clients-but we pride ourselves on knowing what the ultra-wealthy client
wants and giving our clients access to services and investment
opportunities that will fit their needs and lifestyles. For instance,
we have the ability to facilitate the acquisition of fine art, or
advise families on property, casualty and health insurance needs. This
insurance advisory service is a client need frequently overlooked by
most institutions.
We recently launched Private Philanthropy
Advisors, a division that I expect we will spin off as an affiliated
company, whose mission is to assist clients in turning their passions
into legacies.
Grove: What types of investments are available to clients of NYPB&T?
Fuhs: Our
clients want special investment opportunities and we are fortunate to
be able to leverage the Milstein family's, the bank's and other
client's access to some very unique and high-quality co-direct
investments. We have been able to deliver most of these investments
to our clients on the same terms as the other co-investors, without any additional fees, as an added value.
Grove: How much investing is done in-house?
Fuhs: We believe there is a natural conflict in the traditional roles of trustees and money mangers. With the exception of some fixed
income
and cash management accounts, we do not manage assets at the private
bank, nor do we create proprietary investments for the sole purpose of
selling them to our clients or other investors.
However, clients
recently have asked to invest in hedge funds and private equity along
side the bank's capital markets group. In response to these requests,
we structured a fund that attempts to mirror those investments. The
cost of our structuring this fund is subordinated to our clients'
receiving a minimum return.
Grove: Given your name, will New York continue to be your only location?
Fuhs: Local
service is imperative when dealing with the ultra-affluent and we are
in the process of expanding our presence on a state-by-state basis to
capture the specific business opportunities in each community. Case in
point, we've just hired Diana Cantor as the president and CEO of
Virginia Private Bank & Trust. She has an impressive background in
financial services and is probably best known for her development and
advocacy work on 529 college savings plans.
Grove: Do you have other regional locations?
Fuhs: We've
identified two locations in the Midwest that we're in the process of
opening. In fact, we've just named Kurt Miscinski from the private
wealth management division of Deutsche Bank as the president and CEO of
Chicago Private Bank & Trust. Irv Leonard, a former partner at the
Cleveland-based law firm Jones Day, will be his counterpart at Ohio
Private Bank & Trust. Right now we like the potential in Houston
and parts of California and Arizona, as well.
Grove: What other unique things are you doing?
Fuhs: We're
starting a business focused exclusively on the private banking needs of
professional athletes and entertainers-All Pro Private Bank &
Trust. We think there's a big opportunity to make a difference in this
market segment and are very excited about it.
Grove:
Coincidentally, I've just co-authored a book called Fame & Fortune
about the unique financial concerns of high-profile wealth. What are
the issues that you find most prominent among athletes?
Fuhs: The
limited window for earning is the most obvious, but the by-product of
that situation is that most athletes don't have much, if any, of the
money they earned during their career by the time they retire. Say a
football player signs a 5-year $40 million contract, he suddenly thinks
he's worth $40 million! The spending can get out of control, but the
$40 million is part of a long-term contract that is contingent on a lot
of things including his continued good health. We can help athletes get
the smart solutions in place to prepare for the next phase of their
life.
Grove: Can you describe your client base?
Fuhs: We
have more than 200 clients in New York with average liquid assets of
about $30 million. The relationships range in scope from simple
deposits to fixed income management, all the way to co-investing
opportunities.
Grove: How do you and your clients find each other?
Fuhs: Accountants
and attorneys are an important source of new business for us. They know
who is planning for liquidity events and the types of services that
will be needed. They also know when their clients are dissatisfied with
specific providers and can step in and provide a recommendation. We get
referrals from our strategic partners, like the philanthropic
consultants. Also, Howard plays a key role in building the business as
well. His professional and personal networks have produced a lot of new
relationships, as has Emigrant Direct, the online division of the
original banking entity. They've done a good job predicting interest
rate movements and have used it to attract more than $8 billion in
deposits across roughly 400,000 new accounts.
Grove: How much business do you get from existing clients?
Fuhs: Probably
less than other private banks, but it's still early in our life cycle.
We know that most wealthy individuals have several banking
relationships, and when we find new clients they are usually looking
for something specific they can't get from their other banks. We might
compete for a loan or offer a unique co-investment opportunity- most
relationships will start small and evolve over time.
Maybe more
importantly, our clients act as an informal network to one another and
that's truly valuable. Getting the experience and perspective of
someone that has faced the same issues is very useful to our clients,
especially business owners. I can think of one case where two of our
clients partnered on a specific venture after we introduced them. Those
types of things generate a lot of goodwill for everyone.
Grove: What trends are influencing your business strategy?
Fuhs: "Open
architecture" product platforms are ubiquitous these days. Almost
anyone can set-up shop on their own and offer their clients the same
types of products as their competitors, so there's no currency in pure
product anymore. We find that especially wealthy clients want help
managing their situation, applying the products to their specific
needs. Things like setting-up a trust for a new grandchild, buying a
jet without creating excessive personal or business exposure, settling
an estate. As a result, we will keep emphasizing personalized services
instead of products.
The second thing we see is growing
disenchantment among law firms and accounting firms with the
infrastructure costs associated with trust and estate administration
and the liability of fiduciary work. We can be an outsourcing solution
by making available the same services we provide our own clients to law
firms and accounting firms for their clients. We recently formed a
division called Private Label Special Services to provide an
outsourced, turn-key, private labeled trust and estate administration
service for the law firms, accounting firms,
multi-family offices,
registered investment advisors and community banks that want to deliver
full wealth management services to their clients, without exposing them
to a competing financial institution.
Most banks will agree to
manage unique assets, such as real estate or operating businesses, as a
fiduciary only if they are indemnified from risk. NYPB&T is one of
the few private banks that will manage these assets in a fiduciary
capacity if the underlying business or real estate passes our due
diligence review. We think there is some untapped growth to be had as a
services provider and it nicely rounds out our portfolio of businesses.
Grove: You've
spent a considerable portion of your career working with wealthy
families and family offices. What do you make of the recent influx of
multi-family offices?
Fuhs: In
my experience, affluent families want everything from asset management
to tax preparation to bill paying. Very few firms can deliver such a
broad range of services at a competitive price and still make money. It
will be interesting to see if all these players can stay in business.
To
his credit, Howard has approached this venture with a long-term view. I
spend most of my time focused on development, starting relationships,
understanding client needs, activities that don't generate immediate
revenue, but will lay the foundation for servicing our clients and
building our future.
Grove: Speaking of the future, what's in store for NYPB&T three-to-five years down the road?
Fuhs: We
will continue to expand regionally through partnerships with local
families and a portable systems and operations infrastructure.
Controlled expansion allows us to properly vet each opportunity, find
the best professionals, attract the right types of clients, and
maintain very high standards. There's an extremely promising future for
the bank.
It doesn't take money to make people unique, but having money often results in
a set of requirements and preferences that are particular to the state of being
wealthy. So who better than a billionaire to reinvent the private bank for the
21st century? Howard P. Milstein, founder of New York Private Bank & Trust,
expands on the above comment by sharing his perspective on the moneyed set and
explaining how that knowledge will translate into a better banking experience
for ultra-affluent individuals and families.
"Wealthy families like ours require the same kind of diligence and
talent in wealth management advice that was applied when their wealth
was originally created. This means the bank must act as a fiduciary for
our clients in every respect, there must be complete transparency in
everything we do, and we must align our employees' compensation with
our 'clients first' philosophy.
"We
understand that many wealthy families want to preserve their capital
base and compound their wealth, so our investment approach
relies on
sophisticated processes to do just that. Beyond asset allocation and
third-party manager selection, the only "products" we offer are
co-investments-the very opportunities that we take advantage of
ourselves and consider an important and interesting part of our
investment portfolio. Furthermore, our clients can invest alongside the
bank on a completely fee-subordinated basis; they get the same terms we
do and because we have significant 'skin in the game' our commitment is
clear.
"But we know that making wise investments is not the only
concern of wealthy families. Keeping the unique traditions and values
of a
family alive, and ensuring that subsequent generations are
motivated to fulfill their own potential has become increasingly
important. Some affluent families achieve this by bestowing financial
security upon future generations so they may explore their passion,
whether through philanthropy, the creative arts or some other area of
interest. Others may simply guide younger family members on the path to
productive lives or encourage them to give back in ways that better
society as a whole. There is no 'right' answer, it depends entirely on
the family and its priorities. We know this because we've faced many of
these issues ourselves and worked with other wealthy families to
address these concerns.
"Drawing on our experience and taking
a steady approach to implementation has helped deliver billions of
dollars on the $90 million investment made just 20 years ago... and
create the New York Private Bank & Trust you see today."