It wouldn’t be the holiday season without Scrooge.

WalletHub’s 2015 Most and Least Charitable States notes 10 of this year’s Grinches, dominated by states in the northeast and the Rust Belt regions. You can see the most charitable states by clicking here.

WalletHub ranked the states based on eight metrics: volunteer rate, percentage of population donating time and money, median contribution to charity, growth of charitable givings, percentage of adjusted growth income donated, number of public charities, volunteering hours per capita, and whether community service is required for high school graduation. The least charitable are in reverse order.

10. Wisconsin

While Wisconsin has the second highest volunteer rate in the country, it lacks a community service requirement for high school students and ranks poorly in the percentage of adjusted growth income donated by its residents.

9. New Jersey

Being ranked the 42^nd-most-charitable state in 2015 is actually an improvement for New Jersey, which was ranked 47 in 2014.

8. Pennsylvania

Despite having above-average volunteerism, Pennsylvania ranked 38^th in the number of people who donated money, and 41^st in total income donated.

7. Michigan

Michigan’s generosity is growing, as it ranks 23 in growth in charitable giving and 18^th in volunteer rate, but the state’s charitable contributions have yet to recover from a decline attributed to the Great Recession and the repeal of many income tax incentives for giving.

6. New York

New York ranked highly for number of charities per capita, but had the second-lowest volunteer rate in the country, an also ranked low for percentage of the population who claim to have donated time, 44^th, and number of volunteering  hours per capita, 47^th.

5. Kentucky

Kentucky had the lowest percentage of population to claim to have donated their time to charity, half the percentage of Utah, the national leader.

4. Arizona

Arizona ranked 47^th in number of charities per capita, 46th in percentage of the population who claimed to have donated their time, and 38^th in volunteer rate among states.

3.     California

While California residents rank among the nation’s wealthiest, they also give one of the lowest percentages of their adjusted growth income to charity and rank 35^th among states in volunteer rate.

2.     Louisiana

Louisiana ranked 50^th in volunteer rate, its residents logged in one-quarter the volunteer hours per capita that their counterparts in Utah, the national leaders in volunteerism.

1.     Rhode Island

Despite having the 13^th highest number of charities per capita, Rhode Island ranked 47 in percentage of population to have donated time, 48^th in number of volunteering hours per capita, and 40^th in volunteer rate.