Subscribe_102011
RIA Survey 2011
Click Here



Financial Advisor magazine on twitter

LinkedIn-logo

facebook

Online Extras

Print |
June 20, 2011

What Should Advisors Really Fear About Social Media?

Good advisors shouldn't be motivated to begin using social media out of fear.
By Kevin Darlington   
"Advisors who are not engaging in social media will get left behind." If you've heard any practice management pundit speak on the topic of social media, you've likely heard some version of that statement.

While social media is a timely topic, and one advisors should definitely have on their radar, the rhetoric has grown feverish, amplified by countless "experts" in the industry all beating the same drum. But good advisors shouldn't be motivated to begin using social media out of fear.

Every firm, from the two-person RIA shop to the largest national brokerage, can afford to take a measured, deliberate approach to social media. Those who decide not to dive into the deep end of the social media pool may, believe it or not, wake up tomorrow and find that their business has not dried up, clients still talk to them like trusted advisors, and they are still finding new prospects. In other words, technology changes rapidly, but personal behavior changes more slowly.

As you think about taking a more measured approach, what question should you ask yourself? How can any medium, including social, be exploited to meet my business objectives?

Ultimately, if you come to the conclusion that investing a considerable amount of time in social media will not help you meet your business objectives, then why bother? Of course, as a marketer I'd bet that if you did your homework and looked at the facts, you'd find compelling reasons to invest time in social media as one way to help grow your practice. A recent report by Social Media Examiner found it was small businesses that benefited most from using social media. This makes sense. Small businesses like wealth management practices or even advisory teams within larger firms are more able than large, anonymous corporations to engage in the two-way dialogue this medium requires.

The difference we see between those firms that see results and those that don't stems from an investment in the necessary long-term operational and cultural changes that effective social media adoption requires. And make no mistake: Effective use requires a significant commitment of time. The Social Media Examiner's study demonstrates that those who commit at least six hours a week see significant returns.

It's not difficult to be "out there" and visible. Setting up a Twitter account, a Facebook page or a personal blog takes minutes. But unless your content has distinction and relevance, you're just adding to the noise.

This is what advisors should fear in the social media world: irrelevance.

A Unique Challenge For Advisors

Investors and the industry have wisely evolved from a transactional sales-and commission-driven business to one that values deep relationships, planning and advice. Whether you're a broker-dealer, an RIA or both, you have an obligation to your clients that your advice to them be suitable to their situation.

This is what makes effective adoption of social media particularly tricky for advisors. Your business is financial advice. Your marketable differentiator is your expertise in this domain. So how do you market this through social networks, which are not a one-to-one communication channel? This question is crucial for every firm to figure out before diving in.

Finra Guidance

I've come full circle on my views of the guidance Finra has provided. When I originally read Notice10-06, I felt that Finra had shackled broker-dealers from effectively exploiting a powerful communication channel. I've come to recognize, though, that 10-06 is beneficial to the industry because it seeks to ensure that the advice model stays pure, which is to say, one-to-one.

Admittedly, their guidance needs some fine-tuning, but it is sound policy to steer clear of providing any specific recommendations through this channel, since it is impossible to ensure any level of suitability for an audience that is essentially wide open.

It's not easy to thread the needle of not providing specific recommendations while still providing relevant, insightful information that has value.

So, What's an Advisor to Do?

The main measure of the effectiveness of social media use is the quality of connections you make through the channels. Your primary means of making and keeping quality connections will be insightful, relevant content that echoes your firm's expertise, values and point of view.

A mistake many advisors have made is to pick up the social media bullhorn and begin spewing irrelevant information. One advisor we followed (note the past tense) took to using Twitter to broadcast two or three motivational quotes a day. Enough said.

Keeping Your Audience Tuned In

There are a variety of tactics for cultivating an ongoing social media presence. The steps outlined below are just a subset of a broader strategy. These are the steps that can be among the most challenging, but also the most crucial.

One reason marketers are so enthusiastic about social media is that it's free and open. Because of this, more advisors from firms small and large will start using it every day. Breaking through the clutter and keeping your audience tuned in will become increasingly challenging but crucial.

1. Examine the line between insight and recommendation-stay on the insight side and recognize that insight is extraordinarily valuable and perfectly legitimate as far as Finra is concerned.

2. Define an editorial strategy that articulates the subject matter, themes and tone that complement your firm's expertise and POV. This will mean different things to different types of firms. For example, the larger national brokerage firms abound in proprietary thought leadership, but these firms need to differentiate the types of content they want to let loose into the wild from what they want to offer only to clients. They'll need to determine how to synthesize their content into bite-sized morsels transmittable through social media and available to be passed along by their advisors in the field.

3. Think of your best clients when you are publishing. Are they likely to feel that reading your commentary is a good use of their time? Be hard on yourself and your colleagues who are publishing. If what you are publishing lacks "ownable" insight, then don't bother.

4. Understand the nuances of the different channels and what may make your content valuable and sharable. Twitter, Facebook, LinkedIn, YouTube and others have different inherent strengths. Some are more appropriate for acquisition, some for retention.

Quoting an astute post on the social site Quora: "What makes something emotionally relevant is a bit nebulous, and is affected by many factors, such as a person's mood, the device or site through which they discovered your content, their physical location, etc., but the key here is emotion. It's content that makes you feel something you'd like to share."

Remember when e-mail was still fresh and novel? People would share everything - jokes, riddles, chain letters. Not so much anymore.

We're already beginning to see that same filtering process happen within social networks simply because people have no time for irrelevance. Remember: The main capital you have for making connections is relevant, insightful content. And you only have one chance to make a first impression.

Kevin Darlington is a senior vice president of HNW Inc., an integrated marketing services firm that serves financial services institutions seeking to acquire, retain and grow their share of affluent clients. 

 

What Should Advisors Really Fear About Social Media?

 
Comments
stephsamm  - Don't run the risk of being left behind!   |2011-06-27 05:48:21
Advisors who do not develop a social media presence and social networking strategy will be left behind, and should sit on the sidelines at their own risk. Most advisory practices are going backwards by default with margins shrinking, client turnover, and lack of any viable strategy for bringing in new assets consistently. Why would you not want to gain a competitive edge and leverage one of the best opportunities for building business that I've seen in 15 years in the industry through developing a social media presence?

If you decide to pass on social media, you run the risk of being irrelevant altogether and you will be vulnerable to your competitors. If you can't be found online, you will lack credibility, because your reputation is going to be formed with or without your input. Not to mention, developing a presence is vital to protectingyour reputation given that anyone can publish anything about you, positive or negative (i.e. Brightscope Advisor Pages)!

If you aren't visible where people are spending their time, you will have no opportunity to strengthen existing relationships and develop new ones. Imagine if you decided not to adopt email as a communications channel?

It is true that an effective content strategy will be required in the age of social media to stand out from your competitors, but your "expertise" is not a marketable differentiator any longer. It's the ability to focus on and "connect" with a niche audience through deliberate and consistent engagement.

Expertise is a baked-in expectation of any advisor or team. Too many advisors rely on their expertise to win business, and expertise alone is not effective with social media. People don't care about what you know until they know you care.

In social networking, social skills are of top importance. It is only after you've made genuine and authentic efforts to connect, teach, educate, lead, and inspire through personality and passion that your niche audience is going to care about what you know.

Finally there is no such thing as a "social media expert". But there are certainly those of us who have sat in the shoes of an advisor for many years and understand the nuances involved in persuading people to know, like, and trust us enough to let us into their financial lives for an opportunity to be their trusted advisor. I have no doubt that this can be accomplished through smart relationship marketing and strategic social networking in a wired world. I'm seeing it first hand!

Ignore it at your peril!

Stephanie Sammons
CEO, http://www.wiredadvisor.com/about
TJ Gilsenan  - Social muscles   |2011-06-26 14:34:51
I think you make some solid points. I suggest the primary reason for getting involved in social media is to begin building your firm's "social muscles". How investors gather information and make decisions is becoming more social. If you want to be considered by these investors, you have to be where they are. Doing so is a process. Deciding which platforms to be on, what to include in a profile, who will create content, who will work with compliance, how to integrate with offline efforts, and so on all take time. The sooner you start, the sooner you'll get better.

http://theinteractiveadvisor.com/category/social-media
rpatrick  - Thanks for the dose of sanity   |2011-06-26 09:35:13
Thanks for providing some perspective in what has become a frenzy in our business rivaling the tech. bubble! Social media will be an important conduit for prospect and client touches, no doubt. I fear that advisors are always looking for the magic bullet for prospecting and client retention. Ultimately, good old fashioned personal proactive contact will stand the test of time...even with our up and coming generations X and Y. Consider on-line dating as an analogy; It's one way to initially connect, but if it doesn't lead to a face to face date, it's a waste of time.
ledermark  - Look both ways before you tweet   |2011-06-21 09:47:12
You prescribe a thoughtful and informed approach to social media strategy. Advisors getting started may invoke the sage advice of John Bogle, who advises investors, "Don't just do something, stand there." In other words, listen and filter others' content (with a critical eye) before you create a lasting stream of content.
Please login to write comments.

3.26 Copyright (C) 2008 Compojoom.com / Copyright (C) 2007 Alain Georgette / Copyright (C) 2006 Frantisek Hliva. All rights reserved."

FAgreen_June2011
Click Here

PW_JAN2012
Click Here

Online Extras

2012 Top Five Areas for M&A Activity in Financial Services
The first quarter of each year often brings a feeling of quiet in the M&A business that can be interpreted as either the calm before a storm of activity, or a signal that the year will be light in terms of transactions.
Read more...
 
Fundamentals Aren’t Enough
Financial advisors can dramatically improve their client relationships by paying more attention to the psychology of decision making than to investment fundamentals.
Read more...
 

Market/Economic Commentary

Raise Taxes On Rich To Reward True Job Creators
In this opinion piece, a venture capitalist makes a case for raising taxes on the rich to benefit the true job creators: the middle class.
Read more...

On The Move

The Forum For Sustainable And Responsible Investment Appoints Director
Michelle Clayman, founder of New Amsterdam Partners, joins US SIF board.
Read more...
 
Tactical Allocation Group Names Chief Development Officer
Gene Katz, investment banker and strategic advisor joins TAG.
Read more...
 

Quick Poll

Within the next year, do you expect to be using a smartphone for more business tasks?