May 1, 2017 • Jerilyn Klein Bier
The financial services industry has finally started thinking about how to better serve women now that they’re inheriting much of the nation’s wealth. It’s also time to pay closer attention and listen more attentively to women who are creating wealth. Just because a woman has a lucrative profession, a desk in the C suite or a thriving business doesn’t mean she has her personal and estate planning in order, say financial services professionals who focus on this demographic. In fact, she may be more likely to put this on the back burner given the multiple demands on her time. “Women are juggling all the balls at once,” says Kathleen Stewart, a wealth strategist at BNY Mellon Wealth Management in Pittsburgh. The gender retirement gap is also staring many women in the face. An October 2016 report from Diane Garnick, a managing director and the chief income strategist at TIAA, assumes two recent college graduates—a male and a female—start off in the same position at the same company with the same salary, each saving the same amount for retirement. But to have the same amount of money at retirement, the woman must save almost twice as much of her salary (18%, versus 10% for a man). Garnick identified three major factors driving the gap for women—fewer years in the workforce (about 75% of the time men spend there, suggests Social Security data), the gender pay gap and the tendency to be more risk-averse than men. Women earn 78 cents of every dollar men earn, yet professional women earn an even less equitable 72 cents on the dollar earned by male peers, she found, using data from the U.S. Census Bureau. She also noted that women hold 5% more cash, 4.5% less in equities and 5.5% less in mutual funds. “Advisors have a great opportunity to speak with women about how their family commitments can directly impact retirement goals,” she tells Financial Advisor. “When women decide to take time out of the workforce to support and care for their families, nothing at all changes about their expenses in retirement.” Women planning to take time off should speed up their savings to reach the maximum deduction for that year, she says. Employers can help women save more for retirement, she says, by creating customized qualified default investment alternatives (QDIAs) that include higher-risk/higher-return assets such as direct real estate, large-cap stocks and international stocks. Employers should also consider guaranteed lifetime income options. “Without guaranteed lifetime income, women face longevity risk and overspending risk during a time when they will be facing cognitive decline,” she says. Knowing what women need is one thing; finding advisors to assist them is another. “There is still a lot of gender bias in financial services,” says Adrienne Penta, a senior vice president and the creator and executive director of the Brown Brothers Harriman Center for Women & Wealth (CW&W). “It doesn’t come from anybody with ill intentions, I don’t think,” she says, but rather from outdated attitudes. Advisors often assume a male spouse is making the decisions “even with women who are executives or running businesses or are in other powerful leadership roles,” she says. If there’s no “Mr. Smith,” she says, what doesn’t go away is the assumption that clients place top priority on products, underlying managers, stock selection and investment performance. Women do care about all these things, she says, but they also tend to think more holistically about wealth. Penta and her colleagues have conversations with clients about wealth and all its “intersections,” she says, including careers, family, philanthropy and estate planning. They’re also making more of an effort to ask clients open-ended questions to learn about their pain points and what keeps them awake at night, where they’d like to see themselves and their businesses in five years, and how they plan to speak to their children about their estate plans and succession plans. “I don’t think we can expect our clients to open up and share their lives with us unless to some degree we share our lives with them,” she adds. “That doesn’t mean we have to air all our dirty laundry,” but advisors should say why they love doing their job and working with clients. To help women business owners connect with capital (one of their top challenges), the center hosts Women Founders and Funders dinners. At its February dinner, Jules Pieri, co-founder and CEO of the Grommet, a platform that sources and launches undiscovered products, shared her story for launching the business and overcoming obstacles along the way. Other firms Financial Advisor spoke with also host networking events to educate and connect women who work. Educating Women Leah Bennett, chief operating officer at Westwood Trust in Houston and co-founder of the CFA Women in Investment Management initiative (WIM), also finds that women, especially business owners and executives, tend to think more holistically than men about their businesses and personal finances. “It’s not good or bad, it’s just that men and women are different,” she says. “Women tend to look less at investing in silos,” she says, and more at the impact their decisions will have on themselves and their families. They’re generally more interested in having a full plan instead of just hiring a money manager, she says. And they tend to care more than men about being able to successfully transition their business to the next generation of leaders, whether or not they’re family, she says. She helps her many female clients, including oil and tech industry executives, improve their financial literacy skills and understand appropriate risk taking so they don’t sit on the sidelines. “That cash drag definitely has an impact,” she says. She helps clients understand the importance of diversifying their portfolios, especially executives who are rewarded in stock options and restricted stock. Creating a pro-education environment is not only good for clients but for long-term client relationships, says Bennett, who respects clients with expertise in other fields and meets them at their level of financial literacy. First « 1 2 » Next
The financial services industry has finally started thinking about how to better serve women now that they’re inheriting much of the nation’s wealth. It’s also time to pay closer attention and listen more attentively to women who are creating wealth. Just because a woman has a lucrative profession, a desk in the C suite or a thriving business doesn’t mean she has her personal and estate planning in order, say financial services professionals who focus on this demographic. In fact, she may be more likely to put this on the back burner given the multiple demands on her time. “Women are juggling all the balls at once,” says Kathleen Stewart, a wealth strategist at BNY Mellon Wealth Management in Pittsburgh. The gender retirement gap is also staring many women in the face. An October 2016 report from Diane Garnick, a managing director and the chief income strategist at TIAA, assumes two recent college graduates—a male and a female—start off in the same position at the same company with the same salary, each saving the same amount for retirement. But to have the same amount of money at retirement, the woman must save almost twice as much of her salary (18%, versus 10% for a man). Garnick identified three major factors driving the gap for women—fewer years in the workforce (about 75% of the time men spend there, suggests Social Security data), the gender pay gap and the tendency to be more risk-averse than men. Women earn 78 cents of every dollar men earn, yet professional women earn an even less equitable 72 cents on the dollar earned by male peers, she found, using data from the U.S. Census Bureau. She also noted that women hold 5% more cash, 4.5% less in equities and 5.5% less in mutual funds. “Advisors have a great opportunity to speak with women about how their family commitments can directly impact retirement goals,” she tells Financial Advisor. “When women decide to take time out of the workforce to support and care for their families, nothing at all changes about their expenses in retirement.” Women planning to take time off should speed up their savings to reach the maximum deduction for that year, she says. Employers can help women save more for retirement, she says, by creating customized qualified default investment alternatives (QDIAs) that include higher-risk/higher-return assets such as direct real estate, large-cap stocks and international stocks. Employers should also consider guaranteed lifetime income options. “Without guaranteed lifetime income, women face longevity risk and overspending risk during a time when they will be facing cognitive decline,” she says. Knowing what women need is one thing; finding advisors to assist them is another. “There is still a lot of gender bias in financial services,” says Adrienne Penta, a senior vice president and the creator and executive director of the Brown Brothers Harriman Center for Women & Wealth (CW&W). “It doesn’t come from anybody with ill intentions, I don’t think,” she says, but rather from outdated attitudes. Advisors often assume a male spouse is making the decisions “even with women who are executives or running businesses or are in other powerful leadership roles,” she says. If there’s no “Mr. Smith,” she says, what doesn’t go away is the assumption that clients place top priority on products, underlying managers, stock selection and investment performance. Women do care about all these things, she says, but they also tend to think more holistically about wealth. Penta and her colleagues have conversations with clients about wealth and all its “intersections,” she says, including careers, family, philanthropy and estate planning. They’re also making more of an effort to ask clients open-ended questions to learn about their pain points and what keeps them awake at night, where they’d like to see themselves and their businesses in five years, and how they plan to speak to their children about their estate plans and succession plans. “I don’t think we can expect our clients to open up and share their lives with us unless to some degree we share our lives with them,” she adds. “That doesn’t mean we have to air all our dirty laundry,” but advisors should say why they love doing their job and working with clients. To help women business owners connect with capital (one of their top challenges), the center hosts Women Founders and Funders dinners. At its February dinner, Jules Pieri, co-founder and CEO of the Grommet, a platform that sources and launches undiscovered products, shared her story for launching the business and overcoming obstacles along the way. Other firms Financial Advisor spoke with also host networking events to educate and connect women who work.
Educating Women Leah Bennett, chief operating officer at Westwood Trust in Houston and co-founder of the CFA Women in Investment Management initiative (WIM), also finds that women, especially business owners and executives, tend to think more holistically than men about their businesses and personal finances. “It’s not good or bad, it’s just that men and women are different,” she says. “Women tend to look less at investing in silos,” she says, and more at the impact their decisions will have on themselves and their families. They’re generally more interested in having a full plan instead of just hiring a money manager, she says. And they tend to care more than men about being able to successfully transition their business to the next generation of leaders, whether or not they’re family, she says. She helps her many female clients, including oil and tech industry executives, improve their financial literacy skills and understand appropriate risk taking so they don’t sit on the sidelines. “That cash drag definitely has an impact,” she says. She helps clients understand the importance of diversifying their portfolios, especially executives who are rewarded in stock options and restricted stock. Creating a pro-education environment is not only good for clients but for long-term client relationships, says Bennett, who respects clients with expertise in other fields and meets them at their level of financial literacy.
Please log back in before proceeding.
There was an error logging in. Please try again.
Congrats! You are now logged in. Your exam is being submitted.