Multifamily offices provide many services, including estate planning and family security.
There are more than one million families in the
world with a net worth exceeding $10 million, and our research tells us
that they remain underserved by their financial providers. By
establishing a multifamily service model, you can compete with other
commercial providers for wealthy clients and deliver much-needed
services to these households.
In our October 2004 article, "Family Offices: Assets
and Motivations," we discussed the three principal types of family
office structures-single family, multifamily and commercial. Until
recently, independent practitioners had little to do with the family
office concept as they provided expertise and guidance on an as-needed
basis, usually on financial planning and investments. As financial
advisors have become more knowledgeable about their high-net-worth
clients and, in turn, more powerful in those relationships, a greater
number of practitioners have chosen to enter the family office arena by
establishing a multifamily practice.
Simply put, the multifamily office is one that
caters to the needs of several wealthy families with overlapping needs.
The business entity allows the families to pool their assets to achieve
economies of scale and demand access to institutional products and
pricing schedules, among other things. Traditionally, multifamily
offices were overseen by the "anchor" family-most likely the family
with the largest net worth and the foresight to work collaboratively
with other households to pursue similar goals.
In more recent instances, multifamily offices are
the work of an independent advisory practice that coordinates the range
of services required by the various family members. This works well for
a number of reasons. Advisors, especially those with a financial
planning orientation, often have the greatest depth of knowledge about
a family's financial affairs and can readily spot problems and
opportunities. Advisors also are well positioned to bring in outside
experts, such as personal/family security professionals and antiquities
dealers, to complement their own expertise.
Operating as a multifamily office yields significant
benefits for the advisory practice as well. Research shows that
families serviced in a multifamily office structure can generate four
times the revenue they would in more traditional scenarios.
Furthermore, satisfied families will help bring other families into the
office, which will increase both assets under management and fees.
Building A Full-Service Office
To varying degrees, all multifamily offices offer
four types of services-investment management, administrative support,
advanced planning and lifestyle services.
The core service in all family offices is investment
management. True to form, in our survey of 234 multifamily offices all
of the respondents were providing some form of money management
services. The coordination of other professionals is characteristic of
multifamily offices, and 84% were selecting and monitoring outside
managers on behalf of the families.
Outside hedge fund managers were used at an equally
high rate to their long-only brethren, with 82% of offices having
worked with external professionals at some point within the past 24
months. Hedge funds and funds of hedge funds continue to interest most
family offices, and it is expected that more offices will use them in
the next three to five years.
Administration encompasses a wide range of
activities, and multifamily offices must be actively involved in
coordinating these services in order to stay abreast of all aspects of
their client's affairs. (Figure 1). The two most frequently cited
administrative services by multifamily offices are recordkeeping,
provided by 100% of survey respondents, and assistance with tax
returns, provided by 76%.
Advanced planning entails using legal strategies and
planning techniques to mitigate taxes, enhance wealth, protect assets
and structure charitable gifts. Currently, 70% of multifamily offices
provide or coordinate the estate planning process, a significant
component of advanced planning. The number of family offices offering
estate planning is expected to increase by 12% within three years.
The final group of services offered by some
multifamily offices is that supporting lifestyle choices. By and large,
lifestyle services are offered for strategic reasons, principally to
help the families operate as more cohesive units and to strengthen the
bond between the provider and the member families. Lifestyle services
are as different as the families themselves and can include a wide
variety of things. Some of the services cited most frequently in our
research with multifamily offices include:
Formal family education programs.
Business and personal/family security.
Concierge services, including travel and event planning.
Assistance developing and managing collections.
Luxury acquisition services.
Managing residences, air and sea vessels.
Search services for at-home assistance, including chefs, nannies, trainers and personal secretaries.
Health-care services, including trust administration and emergency assistance.
One of the most valued lifestyle services is family
security. Understandably, families with considerable assets feel they
are a target for opportunistic companies and individuals. In a recent
survey with families with a net worth of at least $10 million, security
surfaced as the single greatest concern. Additionally, four key
components of security were identified. They are:
Physical safety of the respondents and their families.
Confidentially of personal information and data.
Protection of wealth from theft and fraud.
Protection of property and other material assets.
Today, only 30% of multifamily offices are providing
family security services. Within three years, that percentage will
likely more than double.
If you are evaluating the family office business model, each service
must be considered independently to understand the value it provides in
building long-term alliances with wealthy families. You can further
distinguish yourself by adding those services that are indispensable to
your wealthy clients and those services that are not readily accessible
from your competitors.
DIY Is DOA
The most successful multifamily offices we have
observed are those that build their business around a core offering and
selectively utilize outside experts on an as-needed basis. For
instance, one office with which we have worked provides equity
investment management, such as portfolio construction, security
selection and performance measurement, and they evaluate and manage
outside managers for the fixed-income and alternative portions of their
clients' investable assets. Additionally, this office regularly turns
to unaffiliated tax specialists, trusts and estates attorneys and
family security consultants to meet the needs of their affluent clients.
Understandably, many multifamily practices want to
control all aspects of the service relationship with their clients. As
a result, some organizations choose to create staff positions for the
specialists they use most frequently, and this almost always is a
decision that is costly and detrimental to the practice over the long
term. Having a range of specialists on staff is expensive and can blur
the lines between the roles of each participant. The up-front cost of
owning expertise is high, as is the ongoing compliance and training
required to keep the professionals operating at the highest levels of
competency. Additionally, there is rarely enough specialized work to
keep the experts busy full time, so unless they branch out and assume
other responsibilities, diluting their focus of expertise, the
specialist usually will not cover their own expense. The business
models that work most smoothly and profitably are those that leverage
external resources only when they are needed.
One of the most important areas of specialization for a family office
is estate planning. We asked multifamily offices how they delivered
this expertise and learned that 80% of them believe that bringing the
legal talent in-house is prohibitively expensive. A slightly higher
number, 82%, feel they can still access state-of-the-art advanced
planning strategies with outside counsel and question whether in-house
legal resources would be of similar quality.
It is critical to understand your costs and price
accordingly when working with outside experts. Some firms opt to charge
a single asset-based fee, usually derived from the investment
management services, and use it to cover the costs of the
administrative, advanced planning and lifestyle services. This is
rarely viable, and will quickly eat into your profit margins.
An accepted practice among multifamily offices is an
a la carte approach in which a range of services is available and each
is priced separately. This method allows for the differences between
the services-a close protection professional, for instance, may have a
flat daily rate while the cost to find a live-in chef may be a one-time
fee calculated as a percentage of the chef's annual compensation-and
the inconsistencies of client use.
In conclusion, the number of independent advisory
firms operating as multifamily offices is increasing as a way of
simultaneously expanding client relationships and business
profitability. To compete with the best you must offer a meaningful
range of services and create partnerships with professionals who
complement your expertise.
Hannah Shaw Grove is the author of
five books on private wealth and advisory practice management. Russ
Alan Prince is president of the consulting firm Prince & Associates.