The fight against election misinformation has a new target: your cable company.
Critics of networks like Fox News and Newsmax argue that the outlets fueled uncertainty about election results and should be dropped by cable providers, just as Facebook Inc. and Twitter Inc. have begun to more aggressively police their content. After this month’s riot at the U.S. Capitol, they say, telecom giants should rethink the programming they beam to millions of homes.
It won’t be an easy battle. Fox News was the most watched cable-news network in the U.S. last year, and any attempt to squelch the outlet will be seen as an attack on free speech. No cable TV distributor has said they’re even thinking of dropping the network. And there are plenty of reasons why, including statutes enforced by the FCC.
Some of the biggest pay-TV providers, including AT&T Inc. and Comcast Corp., own their own news channels. If they drop a competing network, its owner could file a complaint with the U.S. Federal Communications Commission, arguing that they’re violating a rule prohibiting them from giving preferential treatment to their own outlets.
Even providers without their own news networks say their hands are tied.
“Network owners (and their editorial boards) are responsible for the content that they deliver to us,” Dish Network Corp. said in a statement. “Provided that the content is legal, contractually we generally do not have the ability to unilaterally edit content or remove channels from our lineup.”
No distributor has reached out to Fox about canceling, according to a person familiar with the matter who asked not to be identified.
But the drumbeat for cable companies to act has grown louder. Oliver Darcy, a media reporter at Fox News rival CNN, said after the riot that “it is time TV carriers face questions for lending their platforms to dishonest companies that profit off of disinformation and conspiracy theories.”
‘Should Be Booted’
New York Times columnist Nicholas Kristof said that “cable providers should be asked why they distribute channels that peddle lies.” And Washington Post columnist and CNN analyst Max Boot wrote that cable providers should “step in and kick Fox News off.” If Newsmax and rival One America News Network “continue to incite viewers, they, too, should be booted off,” he added.
Dropping Fox News has been discussed on customer forums at AT&T and Comcast, and everyone from Mother Jones to Breitbart News weighed in on the idea over the past week.
OANN President Charles Herring denies that his company’s programming spurred anyone to storm the U.S. Capitol, calling the notion “absurd.”
Though Fox News’s prime-time commentators raised the specter of the election being stolen from Donald Trump, the network called the race for Joe Biden on Nov. 7. In fact, it called a key state, Arizona, well before other outlets.
Newsmax described calls to drop the channel from cable packages as “blatant censorship” and said it never denied the election results, though it did call the race for Biden far later than other channels.
“We called all contested states for Biden as they were certified and accepted him as president-elect on Dec. 14, following the Electoral College vote,” Newsmax spokesman Brian Peterson said.