9. New York-Newark-Jersey City, N.Y.-N.J.-Pa. MSA

Enjoy open-air ice-skating and hot cocoa at Rockefeller Center, then take the water taxi to Jersey City for interactive family fun at Liberty Science Center. Metro New York, the largest MSA in the U.S., ranks second in cold weather activities, fifth in attractions, but 32nd in lowest local costs. Total Score: 61.85.