Subscribe_april2012

Sponsored by:

FA News

Print |
January 11, 2010

Groups Fight Fiduciary Standard 'Myths'

Various organizations from across the financial spectrum have penned a letter to Congress asking them to resist efforts to weaken proposed legislation requiring all financial advisors to abide by the fiduciary standard of care that’s embedded into the Investment Advisers Act of 1940. 

In the joint letter to leading members of the Senate Committee on Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs, seven groups voiced support for an investor protection measure in the Senate’s draft regulatory reform bill that’s part of the attempted overhaul of the nation’s financial system.

In particular, the groups says that Section 913 of the “Restoring American Financial Stability Act of 2009” would provide “straightforward and sensible” consumer protection by eliminating the broker-dealer exemption from the Investment Advisers Act. That exclusion enables brokers to avoid registering as advisors if the advice they provide is incidental to selling securities.

“For too long, brokers have been free to market themselves as trusted advisers and offer extensive advisory services without having to meet the fiduciary standard appropriate to that role,” the organizations said. The draft bill “eliminates the legislative loophole that has allowed this dual standard to persist.”

The participating groups comprise the Consumer Federation of America, the North American Securities Administrators Association, Fund Democracy, the Investment Adviser Association, the Certified Financial Planner Board of Standards, Inc., the Financial Planning Association and the National Association of Personal Financial Advisors.

The groups’ letter included a fact sheet that attempts to debunk the perception put forth by some industry lobbyists that the proposed bill imposes a one-size-fits-all regulation on all people who provide investment advice, or that it would impose burdensome costs to advisors, or that applying the fiduciary standard across the board denies investors access to products and services.

The fact sheet also attempts to refute that the Senate bill would prevent firms from charging commissions, would impose a fiduciary standard on self-directed accounts, or wouldn’t allow advisors to engage in principal trading (though the Investment Advisers Act does impose some limitations on that activity).

The fact sheet can be found on the Consumer Federation of America’s Web site at http://admin.consumerfed.org/elements/www.consumerfed.org/file/finance/Myths-Facts%20Fiduciary%20Duty.pdf.

Groups Fight Fiduciary Standard 'Myths'

 
Comments
marmstrong  - Fact Sheet   |2010-01-12 09:15:06
The "fact sheet" should more aptly be called an opinion sheet since that is all that it is.

Myth: Under the bill, simply providing a one-time recommendation of a stock or bond would impose an ongoing duty to monitor the investment and the account.Fact: The parameters of an adviser’s fiduciary duty depend on the scope of the advisory relationship. Thus, a fiduciary obligation to monitor the account is triggered in circumstances in which there is a promise of ongoing account management or advice. Where no such promise is made or implied, no fiduciary obligation to provide on-going monitoring of recommended investments exists. Thus, brokers giving transaction-specific investment advice would not be subject to a duty to provide ongoing monitoring of the investment recommendation indefinitely, absent a promise to do so.

That seems to have been an issue in the RAND report and little is being done,in my opinion, to clarify to the consumer that the broker will not be their watchdog.
Please login to write comments.

3.26 Copyright (C) 2008 Compojoom.com / Copyright (C) 2007 Alain Georgette / Copyright (C) 2006 Frantisek Hliva. All rights reserved."

 PW May 2012
Click Here

Online Extras

Putting Retirement Changes Into Perspective
Three major shifts are fundamentally changing retirement, says Columnist Robert Laura.
Read more...
 
Consider Adapting Asset Allocation To Retirement Spending Needs
“Chasing yield” can lead investors to buy questionable investments merely because they offer—at least temporarily—enticing income streams. To effectively manage retirement income, it’s important to consider the actual liabilities.
Read more...
 

FAgreen

Chesapeake Director’s Firm Paid $343 Million Amid Ties
Chesapeake Energy Corp.’s decision to cut directors’ pay and other perks may save the company up to $1.65 million a year without addressing investors’ concern that the board failed to rein in Chief Executive Officer Aubrey McClendon’s borrowing and spending spree.
Read more...

On The Move

LPL Financial Names Executive Vice President Of Business Consulting
Robert Comfort will lead business consulting for institutional services division.
Read more...
 
LPL Financial Names Managing Director And Chief Human Capital Officer
Sallie Larsen brings more than three decades of human resources experience to her new role.
Read more...
 

Quick Poll

Do you think buying Facebook shares now is a good idea?