What makes some of the biggest investment advisory firms in the country tick?
For Wealth Enhancement Group, the $1.2 billion firm
in Burnsville, Minn., it's about running their 95-person company like a
finely honed machine so they can absorb the $30 million in new money
they get each month. For Lee Financial in Dallas, it's about providing
very wealthy clients with world-class investment choices. At
RegentAtlantic, it's about harnessing their growing reputation to
become the go-to firm for attorneys in their northern New Jersey
neighborhood. And at RNC Genter Capital Management, it's about
providing institutional-level investment choices to individual
investors, including rock stars, entertainers and national sports
figures.
These firms' multifaceted strategies for building
bigger, better, more profitable firms have created an enlightening
primer for the rest of the industry. But while the advisory firms that
make up the $1 billion-plus segment of the industry can be
relatively divergent in terms of how they do business, it's their
assertive and strategic similarities that set them apart from their
peers. Most have formalized management and marketing, along with
standardized operating procedures, they operate against benchmarks, and
they have made growth a real and measurable goal.
Lately, another similarity has included coping with
growing pains-the kind that stem from adding millions of dollars every
month to the portfolios they manage. But unlike other firms that have
to keep reinventing themselves every few years when they become
overwhelmed with growth, these businesses incorporate the management of
growth into their existing business models.
"Independent advisors have stolen market share from
wirehouses and regional broker-dealers for the past 11 years running,
and there's no reason to think that won't continue," says Chip Roame,
managing director of Tiburon Strategic Advisors, the Tiburon,
Calif.-based financial services consulting firm.
There are far worse problems, of course, than
growing pains. In fact, the 74 independent investment advisor firms
managing $1 billion or more in client assets have been growing assets
20% annually for each of the past three years. Which means that the
assets that this group of large advisors manages will hit the $232
billion mark by year-end, says Nicholas Stuller, managing director of
Financial Information Group in Red Bank, N.J., which produces the
Discovery Essential Databases on independent advisors.
The growth rate of these top firms is very visible
to Deborah McWhinney, president of Schwab Institutional. Four years ago
when she stepped into her current post, Schwab had one client, Ken
Fisher of Woodland Hills, Calif., with more than $1 billion in assets
under management. Today, it counts 30 advisory firms among its clients
with $1 billion asset bases.
To find out what these firms are doing to be able to
grow by leaps and bounds and still provide the kinds of services
wealthy and sometimes very wealthy clients demand, we asked advisory
executives and consultants from across the country how they're doing
it. Here's what they told us.
How important is professional management? To be able
to take on the $30 million in new money that is pouring into its
coffers every month, the $1.2-billion Wealth Enhancement Group has
created a highly efficient operation, run by a professional
(nonadvisor) CEO whose job is to remake the firm into the efficient
machine it's in the process of becoming. "We hired Jeff Dekko two years
ago. He's known for taking companies our size and growing them big,
which is what we're looking for," says Peg Webb, a senior vice
president and partner at the firm. "It helps that he didn't know our
business (although he has taken the exam to become CFP certified)
because it helps him think outside of the advisor box and be more
objective."
Dekko overhauled the firm's technology last year, a
necessity for the kind of efficiency that will allow The Wealth
Enhancement Group to hit its goal of doubling its assets in the next
three years. Technology can also allow firms to grow without having to
hire as aggressively.
Finding good people is as big a challenge for firms
like Wealth Enhancement as it for smaller firms, even though it is
willing to pay hard-charging, experienced professionals as much as
$500,000 a year. Webb says that while the firm can find folks to hire,
"We have a really hard time finding good people. Where are those
hardworking, workaholic people willing to put in the hours and prove
themselves?" she asks.
Standardized practices and defined departments and
teams also help the firm grow without glitches-a key necessity
considering this Midwestern shop caters to clients who have assets
ranging from $300,000 to $700,000. That's in sharp contrast to the
typical clients of the 74 "big" independent advisory firms in the
industry, who have average account sizes of $2.8 million, according to
Discovery Essential Databases.
There are 12 advisors in Wealth Enhancement's
financial planning department. The firm also has investment planning,
tax planning, estate planning, insurance, marketing, compliance and IT
departments. The sharp segmentation allows professionals at the firm to
maintain their focus and process clients and assets efficiently.
"As an advisor, I watch no money. My day is
typically filled with meetings in front of five different clients. I'm
face to face with people eight to ten hours a day," says Webb. "It
helps that I don't have to worry about making the appointments, since
our marketing department sets all appointments with new and existing
clients. They fill my calendar."
So does the weekly business radio program the firm's
partners have been doing for the past ten years, which reaches more
than 500,000 listeners.
So far, the payoff has been significant. The firm
grossed $16 million in revenues last year and expects to pull in $20
million this year. That means salaries in the $500,000 to $1 million
range for the 12 advisors and partners at the firm, Webb says. "While
we're still ahead of the game in terms of profitability, we do feel
downward pressure. That's why the whole focus of 2005 is creating
greater efficiencies."
Down in Texas, Dallas-based Lee Financial
Corporation, helmed by investment virtuoso Richie Lee, is seeing
competition heat up. The firm manages or oversees $1.5 billion for
about 100 high-net-worth clients, many of them entrepreneurs. The
average client brings between $6 million and $10 million in investable
assets to the firm, but some clients are significantly bigger.
So far, Lee vanquishes most competitors because of
his innovative investment strategies and long track record. "Forty
percent of our investments are in alternative strategies, and it's been
that way for 30 years," Lee says. "We created a fund of funds 15 years
ago and use different hedge fund managers, both long and short, who are
excellent stock pickers. We also use private equity and debt and
arbitrage funds. We made a meaningful investment in distressed debt and
energy when the market was down, and it's really paid off for us."
"There's always someone else clients are looking at
when they have $4 million or more to invest, but one of the reasons we
don't see more of it is because our clients are happy and we have an
excellent referral base," Lee says.
To be sure, Lee runs a nimble ship with a staff of
40. But he also admits that he's going to have to "professionalize"
certain functions at the firm that have done well up to this point
without full-time devotion-especially if he intends to hit his growth
and profitability targets in the years to come. "We're trying to grow
the top line by 15% to 20% this year, but absolutely, profitability has
gotten more challenging," he admits.
Hiring a marketing director might be one of those
full-time necessities soon. Lee Financial is the only firm we talked to
that does not have a formal marketing director, much less a dedicated
department. "We're going to have to bring professionalization to
marketing, as we have with other areas, but frankly I think this task
has gotten away from many firms because it hasn't been critical.
Referrals and new clients have been plentiful," Lee says. "But we will
hire a marketing director one day."
The greatest challenges for his firm right now, Lee
says, is managing growth and finding good, qualified people who fit the
culture of his firm. "Our concern right now is we're growing as fast as
we can grow and still delivering services at the level we're expected
by clients to deliver them," he explains.
Finding good employees isn't as difficult, he says,
as making sure they fit his firm and are placed in the right job. To do
that, he's established a human resources department that is charged
with recruiting new professionals on an ongoing basis. "To the extent
you can't attract, retain and manage the right folks, you're a dead
duck these days," Lee says.
Making sure that everyone works in lockstep when it
comes to marketing and growing the firm is underscored frequently at
$1.05 billion, Chatham, N.J.-based RegentAtlantic. The firm's six
partners hired a marketing manager four years ago to underscore their
commitment to their marketing program.
Consultants agree with this approach. "I think the
thing that helps most firms grow big is they define specific sales and
marketing approaches, whether it's networking or using the Charles
Schwab referral program," says Tiburon's Roame.
RegentAtlantic utilizes these approaches and more. In fact, says the
firm's Director of Business Development Margaret Prentice, "We've spent
the last four years building a marketing culture and knowing that
everyone is responsible for cultivating relationships that yield
referrals. It's in each person's job description. We meet each month as
a group to check on the headway each of us is making. Each person is
evaluated and incented on how well they do originating referrals and
closing them."
RegentAtlantic also constantly reaches out to
leading tax and estate planning attorneys in the area, so that it's on
the definitive short list of referrals they make to high-net-worth
clients in need of a financial advisor. How? The firm hosts a monthly
catered breakfast, complete with speaker, to which it invites
significant attorneys.
To ensure its efficiency and investment prowess
keeps pace with its promises, the firm also invests heavily in
technology and new opportunities for clients. "We've spent $250,000 in
the past 12 months on technology enhancements alone," says Christopher
J. Cordaro, a partner and wealth manager at the firm.
RegentAtlantic also uses its reputation and the
leverage its client portfolio affords to negotiate with custodians,
service providers and even partners on clients' behalf. In addition to
offering a hedge fund, the firm's partners convinced Morgan Stanley to
tinker with its international real estate fund so that it now invests
across Asia and Europe. The firm also partnered with three other
advisor shops to create iRebal, a software program that rebalances
investments and does cash management and tax loss harvesting
automatically (www.iRebal.com).
To ensure that wealth managers have time to be
creative and detail-oriented, the firm hired a COO, Jennifer
Papadopolo, who handles all day-to-day compliance and operations.
The chief challenge for the partners? Finding enough
good staff to allow them to meet their goal of adding $100 million in
new assets this year. "We've entered the mode where we're continually
looking for staff," says Cordaro. RegentAtlantic retained a search firm
two months ago to ensure finding talented advisors was a chief priority.
In his latest industry study (Back to the Future:
The Continuing Evolution of the Financial Advisory Business), JP Morgan
consultant Mark P. Hurley predicts that an employee shortage would hit
large firms particularly hard. Cordaro admits it's true. "It takes
about five years for an advisor to get good, and we just haven't put
enough of them in the incubator," he says.
For RNC Genter Capital Management, which manages
about $2.2 billion for entertainers, sports figures and institutions,
growth is good. "All told, we're growing at about $400 million a year,"
says president and owner Dan Genter.
The problem is, that doesn't always translate into
added profitability. "Cost structures are increasing for personnel and
operations, and fees are staying flat or even coming down a little, at
the same time we're required to provide a higher level of services,"
Genter says.
The solution? You have to have a constant commitment
to human and overall capital expansion, Genter says. "The days of the
highly profitable boutique firm with the folksy model will no longer
work. The successful firm has to navigate its maturation process, be
run by a professional staff and have corporate structures and
reporting. They also have to have a collective mission and know their
story and core competence."
The firm's story is its actively managed investment
portfolios, including its core and blended dividend equities strategies
and its actively managed municipal bond portfolio. "We've been able to
take an institutional-level product and use it with our high-net-worth
investors, so they get the customization and tax management they can't
get in mutual funds."
When asked if he might be grooming the business to
sell it, he says: "Been there, done that." He spruced up the business
before it was sold to Bank of Austria back in 1991 and then ran it for
seven years for them before buying it back in 1998. That taught Genter
a thing or two about the importance of independence. "Now I want to
control my own destiny and the destiny of my clients," he says.