What they are and why you need them.
Early this year, wealth management firm CDHM
Financial Advisors in Itasca, Ill., did a cost benefit analysis and
decided to fire one-third of their client base-or 100 out of 300
current clients. The decision didn't come easy-it was wrenching. But
after running and crunching the numbers, the firm found that the lower
half of their clientele generated only 15% of the firm's revenue and,
based on that assessment, opted to concentrate on the top two-thirds.
In explaining the rationale for the decision, CDHM
financial advisor Kevin J. Meehan says, "It's a process, because it's
not easy to fire clients. In our business planning, we assessed that
the profitability of the lower 100 revenue-producing clients was not
acceptable for our objectives. We also determined that by keeping them
in the firm we were doing a disservice to our most profitable clients
by not having the time that we allocated to the lowest 100 available
for our most important clients."
Four years earlier, in 2001, during the bear market,
CDHM made another crucial decision affecting operations. Dissatisfied
with the cost and performance of many of the money managers it had
brought in to run their client portfolios, they instead shifted to
using less expensive exchange-traded funds, and hired in place of the
other managers "less style-specific, more tactically oriented" money
managers, according to Meehan.
"This both reduced the cost to our clients and
reduced the volatility of their portfolios," explains Meehan. "It
didn't affect our profitability and, as a matter of fact, we found that
our strategies attracted significant amounts of new business while
other advisors seemed to be suffering."
Careful planning went into both decisions. Both were
made as a result of a formal business planning process at CDFM
Financial Advisors. It's a firm-wide effort that takes place once a
year. "You have to have everyone's buy-in to the process," says Meehan,
who views the business plan as a mode of discipline that keeps everyone
on track. "Once it's done, that's really a guideline in our firm for
weekly meetings to assess how effective we've been to implement the
plan we've laid out."
Why don't more financial advisors follow this
prescription? "My observation," says Meehan, "is that more advisors in
the wealth management world treat their practices as just a practice
instead of a business. If you look at any household names of large,
recognized businesses, most successful organizations have a vision and
a purpose. Ultimately, because of their success, one can only assume
that they have detailed, robust business plans."
Mary Lacey Gibson is a small business coach of long
standing, as well as a certified financial planner in San Juan
Bautista, Calif. Many clients are advisors with small practices or just
starting out. For them as well as others, the chief benefit of a
business plan is that "it forces the business owner to examine all
aspects of the business. It allows him to understand the big picture
and how all the details of the business intersect to create the big
picture." Incorporating into the plan a personal vision statement of
where you want your business to go and its mission is also important,
maintains Gibson.
"It always amazes me," she says, "that people in the
planning profession who understand the value of a personal financial
plan for their clients don't have a business plan in place for
themselves. Also, it's really important that advisors don't go to all
the effort of creating a business plan only to throw it into a desk
drawer."
Unfortunately, many do, Gibson says. "Many people
start a business only to create a job for themselves. They are unclear
on the concept of management and get stuck in operational aspects of a
business. What starts out as a passion gets to become something they
dislike, due to not having planned how they would handle the details of
accounting, technology, marketing and management."
Most advisors who take the trouble to craft business
plans and vision and mission statements go through a formal process. By
and large, planners like Meehan and Diane Statham, a franchisee with
Ameriprise Financial Services (formerly American Express Financial
Advisors) in Houston, are pretty straightforward in their approach.
Others, like business coach Gibson and Holly Hunter, a CFP and wealth
manager in Portsmouth, N.H., embrace elements of lifestyle planning
like those popularized by George Kinder in his book, "The Seven Stages
of Money Maturity."
Gibson's coaching business is centered on helping
owners and advisors develop and implement business plans. One such
client, Ann Lefferrier, a planner in Bend, Ore., operated several years
without a business plan. Now she's glad she plans out each year. It's
helped her focus and avoid unnecessary tangents, she says.
"Creating a clear vision statement creates a natural
tension between where my business is today and where I'd like it to
be," says Lefferrier. "This tension, combined with the specific steps
in my business plan, naturally pulls my business towards a future
state."
As for her own business, Gibson sets aside a weekend
in January and creates a two-year working business plan. "On that
weekend," she explains, "I do a thorough revenue review of the past
year. I adjust the year's worth of planning I already have in place,
and add a second year to that to create a new two-year plan. I'm also
thinking about more long-range goals for my business, so that the
two-year goals encompassed in my working plan will move me toward my
long-range goals."
Gibson uses her mission and vision statements as a
starting point for each year's planning cycle. Her planning starts with
an assessment of personal goals, personal risk, and strengths and
weaknesses after which she starts addressing business needs. As
lifestyle guru Kinder instructs, she tries to keep her personal and
business lives in balance.
Gibson refers to her plan, checking with its
benchmarks throughout the year. "For me the plan is the business. It
helps me every day in my business. It represents my business, where I
want to go and activities that will get me there. I don't see it as
something separate from or overlaid on my business. It is my business,
and from it comes the other documents I need to operate, such as
employee manuals, customer service policy and procedures documents, and
strategies for compliance."
Statham's plan, de rigueur with her marketing group
in South Texas, consists of projecting her anticipated gross revenue
for the coming year and laying out strategies for obtaining new clients
to augment those already in-house. Integral to the process is
projecting the number of potential referrals she anticipates and the
number of new clients she expects to obtain through seminar events,
alliances with organizations such as Costco, her natural market of
friends, relatives and acquaintances, as well as her associations with
CPAs, attorneys, realtors and other professionals.
"This process in a sense is parallel to what I do
for many clients," says Statham, a fee-only advisor who has done a
business plan the last five of the ten years she's been with
Ameriprise. "I help my clients set goals, help them collect the data
necessary to analyze those goals, and then provide them with a written
deliverable that offers recommendations about addressing the six key
areas of financial planning to help keep them on track to achieve those
goals. It's an integral part of my business. It keeps me focused on
those tasks I need to address on a weekly basis."
The business planning process also incorporates a
personal vision statement and a mission statement. "We're encouraged to
make certain we properly understand what's important to us personally
and professionally," Statham says.
Meehan's group at CDHM goes through a similar
planning process lasting two to three days. It involves evaluating the
services the firm provides, along with the various
markets they serve. And from that they try to deduce their
profitability for that year.
"Once we assess those issues," Meehan says, "we
decide first what it is we're doing we could eliminate and what it is
we're not doing that could create a better business. It's from that
analysis that you begin to write a business plan. We then target
objectives relating to revenue, client acquisitions and what
marketplaces to develop those clients from. It also involves our
service strategies, marketing strategies, as well as what we need to do
internally as an organization relating to processes and personnel."
He adds, "We look at the business plan as a vision
statement for the business, but within that is a purpose statement for
the firm. Our purpose statement is to provide financial peace of mind
to successful people looking to partner with a successful wealth
management firm."
Hunter's softer but no less disciplined business
planning technique consists of asking clients several questions
involving their goals and values. She describes the process as life
altering for both herself and her clients, and went through it herself
with another financial planner. Today, she says, they mutually support
one another's planning efforts.
Hunter utilizes Kinder's three questions: How would
you live your life? What would you do with your money? Would you change
anything?
"What it has helped for myself and my clients is to
connect our money, our values and our lives," says Hunter. "It's
important to have a written document to formalize your goals and
values, your dreams and passions for your life, what's meaningful. It's
important that a financial or business plan addresses the core issues
of your life.
"I think delivering a business plan without the life
planning would be delivering a lemon," says Hunter. "It's like biting a
hollow [chocolate] bunny. It's all air. There's no substance."
As we've seen, a business plan not only allows you
to stand on the mountain top and see the big picture but gives you the
opportunity to understand all the facets that intersect to create that
panorama. And it can greatly simplify your life.
"Advisors learn to turn off the lights, lock the
door at the end of the day, and go home without taking the business
with them," says Gibson.
Bruce W. Fraser is principal of Bruce
W. Fraser Communications, an editorial services firm in New York City.
He has written for many publications. He can be reached at
[email protected]. Visit him at www.frasernyc.com/home.