Many advisors don't understand what their wealthy clients want-or need.
Being successful in cultivating as well as working with the wealthy often will require financial advisors to be sensitive to a number of planning concerns of their affluent clients and prospects. While this does not mean the financial advisor has to be expert at the various forms of planning, he or she must be adept at recognizing the need and be able to source the proper experts, as well as being able to motivate the client to take action and often facilitate the process.
What proves to be the biggest obstacle is the lack of knowledge most
financial advisors have about their affluent clients. Just consider the
weaknesses of many financial advisors when it comes to really
understanding their better clients. We empirically addressed these
issues when we conducted a study of 1,417 affluent investors
(investable assets of $500,000 to $5 million) and 512 financial
advisors who derive 75% or more of their business from these types of
affluent clients. For our purposes, let's consider three planning
services:
Estate planning.
Asset protection planning.
Charitable planning.
Estate Planning
No matter what happens to the federal estate tax, the affluent
generally want to determine who will benefit from their efforts-how
their assets will be divided. Thus, there is a strong need for estate
planning. This becomes more important when we recognize that 79.2% of
the affluent want to make sure their heirs are properly taken care of
(Exhibit 1).
Most of the affluent investors (69.8%) had estate plans (Exhibit 2). At
the same time, 82.2% of the financial advisors stated that their
clients with $500,000 to $5 million in liquid assets had estate plans.
We already can see the disconnect between the world of the affluent
investor and the perceptions of financial advisors.
What is even more telling is that among the 854 affluent investors with
estate plans, only 11.2% of them have up-to-date estate plans.
Consequently, most affluent investors should seriously consider
revising their estate plans.
What we have found is that many financial advisors make the erroneous
presumption that because a client is wealthy, that client has addressed
his or her estate planning needs. For all sorts of reasons ranging from
a preference for considerable control to fear of death, estate planning
is regularly not being done-even though it should.
For financial advisors, there are tremendous business opportunities
that tend to become apparent when wealthy clients go through the estate
planning process. Life insurance-be it updating what the client
presently has or providing more to meet changing circumstances-is
regularly a product of estate planning. Increased assets under
management are also the norm, especially as assets are placed in trust
structures.
Another form of planning where we see this same pattern of affluent
client need and financial advisor disregard, but only more intensely,
is asset protection planning.
Asset Protection Planning
Of the 1,417 affluent investors we surveyed, 47.3% are very concerned
about being sued (Exhibit 3). Clearly, these wealthy individuals would
make excellent clients for asset protection planning. However, only
12.9% of the wealthy have formal asset protection plans (Exhibit 4).
Like estate plans, asset protection plans need to be continually
updated. Of the 183 affluent investors with asset protection plans, all
of them were three years old or older. In effect, all of them should be
updated.
At the same time, the financial advisors we surveyed misread the
concern over asset protection planning for their affluent clients. Only
20.9% of financial advisors stated that the majority of their wealthy
clients should be looking at asset protection planning. Another 27.5%
considered it unnecessary for their affluent clients. And, more off the
mark, was that 51.6% stated that the majority of their affluent clients
were already taken care of when it came to asset protection planning.
As with estate planning, asset protection planning will likely lead to
the need for financial advisors to provide a variety of financial
products, from life insurance to derivative transactions to investment
management. Once again, financial advisors are off the mark when it
comes to the needs and wants of their wealthy clients. Their perceptual
inaccuracies not only mitigate their own business success, but they are
doing a disservice to their affluent clients.
Charitable Planning
Another area where there is a "disconnect" between the perceptions of
financial advisors and the needs and wants of the affluent is
charitable planning. With 99.2% of the affluent we surveyed engaged in
"checkbook philanthropy," only 21.1% have made planned gifts (Exhibit
5).
At the same time, we find a precipitous gap between the types of
planned gifts the affluent are interested in learning about and what
financial advisors think the affluent are interested in learning about
(Exhibit 6). Case in point: among all the types of charitable gifts,
67.7% of the affluent are interested in learning about private
foundations. At the same time, only 14.5% of the financial advisors
believe their affluent clients are interested in learning about private
foundations. At the other end of the spectrum, 45.5% of financial
advisors believe their wealthy clients want to learn about will
bequests. However, the data shows that none of the affluent are
interested in learning about will bequests.
Conclusion
These three types of planning, which are very often interrelated, are
clearly appropriate and in demand by the affluent. Meanwhile, so many
financial advisors make the presumption that these planning services
are unnecessary for a variety of reasons, ranging from "the client is
all taken care of" to "it's not my job."
Beyond the basics, it's unlikely that the greater majority of financial
advisors are proficient with respect to estate, asset protection or
charitable planning. In our experience, this lack of expertise proves
to be a significant stumbling block for many financial advisors. This
turns out to be a self-imposed limitation.
The affluent do not expect their financial advisors to be adept at all the various planning services. Concurrently, few-very, very few-financial advisors are planning polymaths. The key is for a financial advisor to recognize the need for various planning expertise and be positioned to bring in the appropriate experts. Whether these experts are on staff or professionals with whom the financial advisor has strategic alliances, all that matters is that they can be accessed appropriately.
It is a significant mistake for most financial advisors to try to
become proficient at the various forms of planning. Learning how an
intentionally defective trust works, or the mechanics of a charitable
remainder trust, or the operation of an offshore self-settled trust, is
not nearly as important as learning when to bring in the right
professional.
By being able to deal with the planning concerns of the affluent by
brining in the proper experts, the financial advisor will end up
growing his or her business. The expert planners will end up
identifying opportunities for the financial advisor to provide
products. And, most importantly, the affluent client will be better
served.
Hannah Shaw Grove is the author of five books on private wealth and
advisory practice management. Russ Alan Prince is president of the
consulting firm Prince & Associates.