SMAs can be used to attract foundation and endowment work.
As more advisors incorporate separately managed
accounts (SMAs) into their businesses, they also look for new and
different ways they can use SMAs to take their businesses to a higher
level. Although SMAs have always provided an entree for advisors
wishing to enter the high-net-worth market, they may also provide an
entry point to a lucrative segment of that market-foundations and
endowments.
Are SMAs a good fit for these organizations'
investment portfolios? How can advisors use them to gain entry to this
very lucrative segment of assets? This article will explore how SMAs
are particularly suited to attract foundation and endowment accounts as
well as how to approach them and the families who create them.
The SMA Fit
"We think SMAs are very well suited for the small to
medium foundation and endowment market," says Jeff Carlin, vice
president of Schwab's managed account group. Such institutions have an
even greater need than individuals for the customization SMAs can
offer. "Not only can their mission be maintained in their work, but it
also can be reflected in their investments by having their portfolios
customized and tailored to their specific needs," adds Carlin.
Schwab's trading platform includes 65 of the most
common socially responsible investing (SRI) screens that managers can
use to eliminate entire sectors as well as individual securities. But
not all small foundations and endowments employ SRI; there are many
causes a nonprofit institution may support. Regardless of the focus of
the institution, SMAs offer the flexibility and restrictions needed for
specifically focused portfolios.
"When you look at it from the theoretical standpoint
of what SMAs are designed to do, it's exactly the sort of business that
managed accounts can support for advisors," says Craig Muska, director
of business development at IW Financial in Portland, Me., an
SMA-focused provider that provides extensive due diligence and research
on the environmental, social and corporate governance performance of
companies.
The primary need of foundation and endowment
accounts is to have an investment structure that supports the focus of
the institution, according to Jason Pride, vice president and portfolio
manager for The Haverford Trust Company in Philadelphia. "Many
endowments or foundations have either outlays or incoming assets in the
form of gifts, not in the form of actual cash. The transparency offered
by SMAs allows these institutions greater access to information about
what they own at a specific point in time so the manager can manage the
portfolio around those incoming assets in order to better manage the
entire portfolio."
"The personal nature of the issues involved with
philanthropy actually strengthen the relationship and serve as a good
foundation for incorporating things other than baseline financial
performance," explains Muska.
For nonprofits focused on SRI, Muska says, "There's
a very narrow definition in the investment world of what constitutes
SRI-it doesn't have to be a prepackaged solution. SMAs provide a
customized solution that's really designed to incorporate the client's
values within the investment process. This is a new paradigm-providing
research that leads to custom solutions for investors."
The Approach
Independent advisors may have an advantage over
large institutions in attracting small foundations and endowments as
clients. "Larger firms may have a tougher time because of personnel
turnover. Small foundations and endowments may get lost at larger firms
because of their size. I think the barriers to entry are low," says
Jane Abitanta, principal of Perceval Associates Inc. in New York.
On the other hand, it can be much more difficult
developing relationships with family clients than with individuals.
"The relationship structure required by wealthy families is more
complex than with individuals. Advisors should prepare themselves for
long, long lead times. "You have to be willing to hang in there,"
Abitanta adds.
"You can't just decide to go after the foundation
and endowment market-it's not just another account to a family. It's a
whole different thing," explains Muska.
Two of the primary reasons families establish
foundations and endowments are to establish a legacy for the family and
to provide an educational venue for younger family members to learn to
manage the family wealth. "You have to lose all notions of classic
marketing when you're dealing with families of wealth," adds Abitanta.
"Families are using private foundations for purposes other than the
goal of the private foundation as an entity. It's really a family
issue, not necessarily a philanthropic issue."
Most family clients are business owners and, as
such, tend to be on the boards of other foundations and endowments and
to be active in their own communities, according to Linda Postorivo,
vice president of MAFG RIA Services Inc. in Mt. Laurel, N.J., a
subsidiary of The Beringer Group. "Their peer groups are very similar
so they serve on the boards of various organizations of their friends,
relatives, and associates in their own league."
Family clients tend to spread the word about
advisors who do a good job. "These are the clients to tap as a referral
source," says Pride.
But asking for referrals must be done carefully. There are ways to ask
for referrals that are not so clumsy. Advisors who already have
provided solutions for endowments or foundations can state a desire to
help other families in this way and ask if there are other people he or
she should see. Working as part of a team of advisors for a family
client can position advisors to add more value not only to existing
clients, but also as valuable resources for clients of accountants and
attorneys.
"Private foundations specifically have to file at
tax return called the 990PF," says Carlin, "so working in the same
space with other advisors, such as accountants, can really help
pinpoint issues that may revoke a nonprofit's tax exempt status. Same
thing on the legal side-there are lots of ordinances and acts such as
the Unified Management of Institutional Funds Act (UMIFA) and the
Uniform Prudent Investor Act (UPIA) that can affect governance."
Asking to establish a mutual referral relationship is not necessarily
the best way to go; the advisor's purpose should be to become a
resource to support an accountant or attorney's business. "The
best thing for an advisor to do is to go in to a family or an
organization with a very consultative approach," recommends Carlin.
"Look to really gain insight into how the organization has gotten to
its existing state. Then you can offer suggestions based on their
viewpoint-this is probably the most accepted approach when dealing with
these types of organizations."
Muska adds, "Advisors need to take the time to
understand what motivates a particular endowment or foundation. Is it
personal? Is it strategic? Is there some kind of crisis looking to be
solved? Or is it a combination of all three? The challenge for the
advisor is to engage clients in conversations about their values and
how they actively integrate that with their investment process."
Abitanta says advisors need to know what a family's
issues are and get educated specifically around what they need. Then,
"it's about differentiation," she says. "What's unique about your
investment management offering? What type of relationship are you
willing to create and sustain with the family?"
According to Carlin, the first step an advisor
should take in attracting foundation and endowment business is to look
at his or her existing book of clients. "They should go first to the
clients who are most attuned to their approach from an investment
standpoint and ask them if they are currently gifting money or
currently involved in any eleemosynary organizations," he advises.
"We've found that clients of advisors who have strong businesses
providing high levels of advice are more than willing to introduce
these advisors to the organizations with philanthropic needs."
Pride disagrees and sees it another way. "If you're
trying to see if families are going to be structuring foundations and
endowments, approaching your current client base might work. But
families who have already created these institutions represent a much
larger portion of the market."
What Not To Do
A definite no-no is to try to appeal to a charitable
interest held dear by a family when the advisor doesn't share the same
interest, says Abitanta. "People pick up on your lack of interest and
you become kind of a carpetbagger at that point. And definitely do not
try to go in and sell product as opposed to working in a relationship."
Providing family education is another venue for
attracting families with foundations or endowments. But just offering a
seminar to family clients is a tip-off that the ultimate purpose is to
sell them a product or service. Offering education specifically
designed to address a family's needs directly addresses an important
item on family's lists of criteria for working with an investment
advisor.
Independent advisors truly have the advantage here.
Says Postorivo, "There are very few investment advisory organizations
who truly do not have ties to money management firms or insurance
companies." Complete objectivity is a high priority for families of
wealth.
According to Carlin, "Advisors who want to grow
their businesses are looking for new services to provide high-net-worth
clients. And foundations and endowments are looking for advice, and
they're finding it in the independent RIA space." With the flexibility
of SMAs and the low barriers to entry, the foundation and endowment
marketplace may be the next frontier for advisors willing to provide
the desired level of service.