More schools offer degree programs in finanical planning while academic standards for CFP licensees rise.
Earlier in this decade, some of the profession's
elder statesmen frequently fretted in private about the future of
financial planning. Their concerns were very different from their fears
in the 1980s, when folks wondered if a true profession could emerge
delivering real financial planning services without excessive reliance
on selling high-commission products.
That fear got vaporized in the last 15 years, as
baby boomers' demand for retirement investing advice overwhelmed the
financial services business. Instead, the new worry became whether
there would be a sufficient supply of new advisors to meet the
requirements of an increasingly complex business. But in recent years,
the supply of young advisors has begun to mushroom. Even if there
aren't enough advisors for everyone who wants one, there are enough to
sustain a profession. And they are increasingly well-qualified.
The rules are changing for new CFP certificants on
March 1 of this year, as the CFP Board of Standards will now require
new certificate holders to also have a college bachelor's degree.
Although aspiring planners can major in any subject
they chose, they should take note: Finding a degree program in
financial planning continues to get easier. "Our sense from the
colleges that have degree or credit-based programs is their enrollments
have dramatically gone up," says Colleen McArdell, the board's manager
of initial certification.
There has also been a swell in the number of CFP Board-registered programs, she adds.
Since the board started registering programs in 1986, the number of
college-based programs has grown from just a handful to 324 programs
offered at 192 schools. Most of the growth has taken place since 2000,
during which time the number of programs has gone from 138 to 324.
Of the programs, 179 are certificate programs, 94
are undergraduate, 48 are master's and three are doctoral programs,
according to McArdell.
Several factors seem to be contributing to the
increase, she says. More recognition of financial planning as a
profession is among the major reasons, with colleges adding the field
to their curriculum to prepare students for the job market.
"The barriers are starting to come down, slowly but
surely," McArdell says. "I just think there's a greater recognition
that this is a profession and there are jobs waiting for graduates on
the other end."
Graduates of degree programs typically don't take
their CFP exam until some time after graduation, but the CFP Board is
already starting to see a spike in applications.
In November, the CFP Board hit an all-time high in
certificate applicants with 4,272. That was up from 3,205 a year
earlier and 2,662 in November 2004.
What are the potential advantages of a financial planning degree as opposed to another major?
J. Brent Beene, who graduated with a master's degree
in financial planning from Texas Tech University in 2002, feels the
degree has opened more doors-and opened them more quickly. "There were
a number of people recruiting us right out of school," says Beene, a
financial advisor at RegentAtlantic Capital LLC in Chatham, N.J. He was
originally hired by a New Jersey-based firm that was specifically
targeting financial planning graduates, hiring seven people from his
graduating class.
"I really felt like when I came out from a technical
standpoint that I was ahead of the game in the sense that there were a
lot of concepts I was familiar with," he says. "In financial planning,
until you've done the hands-on work, it's hard to grasp exactly what
you're learning."
Lucas Bucl graduated from Kansas State in 2003 with
degrees in family financial planning and corporate finance. Soon after
college, he was among a crop of new hires at Accredited Investors in
Edina, Minn., which specifically looks for students with a background
in financial planning.
The degree program, it turns out, helped Bucl with
more than just getting a degree. As part of the degree program, he was
able to attend the Financial Planning Association's annual conference
in New Orleans in 2002. There, he got a chance to meet Kathy Longo-one
of the principals at the firm where he was eventually hired. "Being
able to go to the conference created a lot of networking
opportunities," he says.
Bucl, whose title at the firm is financial planner
specialist-a support role to financial planning team leaders-says his
education allowed him to hit the ground running once he was hired.
"Almost everything I learned in the financial
program has been put to use," he says, citing estate planning
strategies and tax planning as two key areas in which college studies
have helped.
Bucl, who is 27 years old, got his CFP in 2005 and
sees as his next step working as a financial planner with clients of
his own. He one day would like to be a partner in a planning firm or
have a firm of his own. "If I start my own business, I would strongly
consider getting an M.B.A.," he says.
A Holistic Curriculum
Texas Tech University began its financial planning
program in 1987, eventually expanding to a graduate program. The school
currently has 200 undergraduates and 60 graduate students in the
program, says William Gustafson, director of the university's Center
for Financial Responsibility and one of the founders of the financial
planning program.
Nine full-time faculty members are devoted to the
program, he adds. The school, which offers a doctorate in consumer
economics, was the first Ph.D. program to be CFP Board registered.
Three doctorate programs are currently CFP registered. "We teach the
holistic model-the whole CFP idea of looking at the whole financial
situation," he says.
Most students in the program aspire to be in such a
practice, and are able to get hands-on experience through internships,
summer jobs and the university's annual attendance at professional
conferences, including the annual meetings of the Financial Planning
Association (FPA).
About 50 to 55 students graduate from the program
each year. "I can't think of any kid in our program willing to move
geographically who goes without a position,"
Gustafson says.
The typical bachelor's degree graduate, he says,
will take a job with a boutique practice, at a starting annual salary
of between $35,000 and $50,000. A fewer number of students will venture
out into new careers. Past graduates include a casino computer security
director and pharmaceutical salesmen.
Gustafson feels one of the primary benefits of
earning a college degree in financial planning or a related field is
the flexibility it provides graduates as they enter the job market.
"You are talking about the difference between a training program and an
educational experience," he says. "You develop a set of skills over
time, and in an intellectual environment where the student can question
and consider alternative viewpoints. If you're in a training program,
there is the way it is, and they're not interested in your thoughts."
The university is currently working on a plan to
provide more hands-on experience for students by creating a financial
planning clinic, says Vickie Hampton, director of the university's CFP
Board-registered programs.
The clinic, which the university hopes to launch in
six to eight months, would expand upon a program in which financial
planning degree students provide financial advice to other students.
"Students need a lot of help with fringe benefits, taxes and other
areas," Hampton says. "It gives them an opportunity to work with real
people."
Planners In Demand
San Diego State University has offered a graduate
program in financial planning for 30 years and an undergraduate program
for 20 years. On the undergraduate level, it offers a bachelor's of
science degree in financial services and a certificate program in
personal financial planning.
Five years ago, the university started an "Executive
Planner" program, designed for financial service professionals looking
to study toward a CFP certification. The program requires three years
of work experience and at least a bachelor's degree.
The undergraduate program consists of about 300 students, with a
typical graduating class of between 150 and 175, says Tom Warschauer, a
finance professor who directs the program.
Graduates of San Diego State, as with other schools
with financial planning programs, often take their CFP exams after a
year or two of work experience, he says. "In the undergraduate program,
about a quarter of the people get their CFP certificate within a year
of graduation," Warschauer says. "Most employers want them to get fully
licensed before the CFP exam."
The financial planning program at San Diego State
has grown along with the profession itself, he says, with the
undergraduate program growing at about 30% a year up until this year,
in which the growth slowed to 15%. The program also enjoys one of the
most successful job placement records on campus, he says. "I think the
ratio of job offerings to graduates is a better ratio in financial
services than any other part of the university, with the exception of
engineering," Warschauer says.
The job opportunities in financial services may not
be something students are aware of when they enter college, but they
are aware of the field's potential by their junior and senior years. As
a result, he says, the financial planning program gets a high
percentage of students who are transfers from other majors.
While students with financial planning degrees may
not get a better starting salary than students who enter the field from
other majors, Warschauer says, "I think they move ahead much more
rapidly. They usually get their licensing done in a faster period of
time."
Among graduate students, about a quarter get hired
by fee-only planners "as support people who turn into financial
planners within a short period of time," he says. A quarter go to work
at accounting, investment management or other professional firms, a
quarter compete with undergraduates for financial services jobs and
another quarter end up in ancillary industries, such as financial
planning software companies, he says.
About two thirds of graduate students will typically
say they expect to be partners in a business or go into business for
themselves, he says. "Students in the financial services major are much
more career focused than in some of the other majors," Warschauer says.
He also notes that about a quarter of the school's graduate students
are international students, many intent on practicing their profession
back in their home countries. "They feel the U.S. has this profession
nailed," he says.
Financial Volunteerism
University of Missouri-Columbia is also among the
pioneers of financial planning studies, having started its
undergraduate program in 1987 and later adding a graduate program.
The undergraduate program currently has about 166
students and the graduate program has seven students, says Robert
Weagley, chairman of the university's personal financial planning
department and one of its founders.
In previous years, the school has had as many as 260
undergraduate majors. Weagley says the drop has been from a combination
of budget cuts and a recent increase in the university's grade point
average requirement for degree majors.
But he thinks the drop is temporary. "I believe that
enrollments will be going up mainly because there is demand out there,"
Weagley says. "Usually a day doesn't go by without us getting a call
from someone (at a company) who wants to talk to students."
The budget cuts have forced the department to reduce
its full-time faculty to four from seven since 2000, he says. "Our
biggest problem here is simply funding," Weagley says.
The program puts a "life planning" focus on its
curriculum, with emphasis on how a planner helps families accomplish
their goals, he says. One of the undergraduate courses, entitled "The
American Dream," deals with topics that include income and distribution
issues and requires students to interview people 65 and older about
their lives.
The program also requires students to take a course
in volunteerism and runs a counseling center in which students provide
tax assistance to low-income families and other college students. "Some
of these men and women have never sat across the table and talked to
anyone like that," he says. "What the students get out of it is real
good communication skills."