Two CPAs spill the beans on how they are growing their advisory firm.
Planners Mike McCabe and Bob Westrick were on the
move in the final days of summer-literally. "We're in jeans right now,
packing up boxes. We're gutting our existing office space," says
Westrick, McCabe's co-principal at WNA Investment Programs Inc., in
Chicago's western suburb of Hinsdale. The crates' destination: the
second story of the building that's been home to the fee-only RIA for a
decade. That's where the principals and their staff of three will camp
for the duration of the facelift. "Our average client today is more
affluent than our average client ten years ago," Westrick says, "so we
want our offices to be more comfortable for them, as well as better
reflect the success we've achieved."
WNA's accomplishments include Westrick being named to Worth magazine's
list of Top 100 wealth advisors this year. McCabe points to the firm's
client-attrition rate-just 2% to 3% over its 13-year history.
Meanwhile, client referrals have been the primary catalyst for growth
that created the shop's second senior planner position this past
spring. By the autumnal equinox, WNA was closing in on its year-end
goal of managing $130 million, roughly half of which is qualified money.
McCabe and Westrick were certified public accountants before they knew
each other and before each became a certified financial planner. Yet
they don't consider themselves accountants, and theirs is not the
typical bean-counter-gone-planner story.
Westrick, 47, hasn't done accounting in forever, although he started
work life at a then-Big Eight CPA firm. But he jumped to the corporate
finance department of the American Hospital Association, and by the
time he had earned an M.B.A. from heady University of Chicago, where
modern portfolio theory struck a chord with him, the fate of his
accounting career was sealed.
McCabe, 45, got his CPA right out of college, too, and eventually
became a Certified Pension Consultant, a credential put to use at a
third-party administrator he became involved with during the 1980s and
eventually co-owned. That led him to his future business partner.
Westrick had a planning firm that was working on a 401(k) case;
McCabe's TPA was brought in on a recommendation from a common
professional acquaintance. The two got on so well, they decided to
launch a fee-only advisory. The name chosen, WNA Investment Programs,
combined and continued the predecessor organizations' brands. "If you
go into business with someone who is competent and trustworthy,
everything else can be worked out," Westrick says.
How They Do It
On paper, what McCabe and Westrick say makes WNA hum-its people,
processes, service and technology-is pretty straightforward. The key,
of course, is in the execution, starting with hiring and retaining
exceptional staff.
The efficient office manager, Sue Bolt, possesses a most pleasant phone voice and regularly wins praise from clients, such as this recent comment to Westrick from a new seven-figure, out-of-state account: "She is a wonderful face on your company." Mary Beth McLean is an associate portfolio manager, as the senior planners are called, who joined in 2002 with 20 years of bank experience, the last five in the private-client group. The new hire, Joe Feldmann, holds both a CFP and a CPA. "We wanted a CPA because they tend to be more analytical, quantitative, disciplined and anal, like us. They just make good research people," Westrick says.
The process utilized to recruit for the position reveals much about the
principals' business savvy. They placed an ad on Monster.com, along
with a detailed job description intended to ward off the
quasiqualified. It was McCabe's idea to require that applicants mail in
their resume, rather than permit electronic delivery with a nonchalant
click of the mouse. "That keeps you from getting a lot of resumes you'd
rather not see," he says.
A much softer touch guides client gathering. During the free initial
consultation with a prospect, "We listen," McCabe says. "We try to
understand what's brought them to us and if it was a bad experience
elsewhere, what went wrong. We don't try to sell-we're both fairly
mild-mannered-we just try to get people to where they want to be."
WNA doesn't target a particular client type, although "our ideal is an abdicator, someone who is willing to listen to us and heed our advice," McCabe says. A long-term perspective is also vital. "People who chase the flavor of the month don't work well with us, and we tell them that. We're successful enough that we don't need every prospect," he says.
Those who come aboard can pay as much as $1,500 for portfolio design and implementation. The process begins with a series of intensive fact-finding sessions with the client, attended by both the principal handling the case and one of the senior planners. Hours of portfolio modeling follow, resulting in a portfolio design recommendation, which serves as the touchstone to money management-the ultimate focus of client relationships at WNA. One hundred basis points are charged on the first $500,000 managed (the firm's minimum), sliding in stages to 50 basis points above $2 million.
What about financial planning? Frequently the fact-finding marathon reveals other needs, and WNA offers, for a separate fee, what might best be described as modular financial planning.
"We focus on just the top two or three areas that can really improve
their situation," Westrick says, citing retirement planning, estate
planning, and insurance as the most common. "We used to do
comprehensive plans, but it overwhelmed folks. They would go into
paralysis and do nothing."
For Westrick and McCabe, the best way to manage risk is to build the
right portfolio for the client, provide education about its potential
benefits and risks and make sure it stays on track. "Investors get hurt
when they sell in bad times. We design portfolios so that clients will
stick with them," Westrick says.
Their first step is understanding the client's true appetite for risk,
even if he doesn't. "During a fact-finding meeting, someone might say
he's aggressive but when you look at the investments he already has,
they really aren't," Westrick says. "You can learn a lot by examining
current holdings."
Behavioral finance also is incorporated. Studies have shown that
investors are more unhappy with a loss of x percent than they are happy
with a gain of the same percentage. "What does that tell you about
portfolio design?" McCabe asks. "That it's better to protect the
downside than to try to shoot the lights out. We think protection of
principal is a big deal."
When the recommended portfolio design is presented to the client, a key
part of the discussion revolves around a graph produced by SunGard
AllocationMaster illustrating the range of expected returns that a
client could experience over various timeframes. "We spend a lot of
time focussing on the worst-case scenario. We want the client to
understand that market downturns will happen and therefore an investor
must be willing to stay the course," McCabe says. Putting volatility in
context helps clients develop the fortitude to tough it out in
disappointing markets.
When it comes to selecting funds, style consistency is a must. "Studies
have found that style consistency is a strong indicator of future good
performance relative to peers," Westrick notes. Typically, only
managers with at least five years of experience in their current style
are considered. Other qualities scrutinized include performance
consistency, the fund's potential capital gains exposure and access to
fund management.
Service Standards
Quality service creates happy clients, McCabe and Westrick firmly
believe. One step they've taken is tailoring the amount of contact to
the client's wishes, data that's easily tracked by Junxure, their
client relationship management software.
Strict standards for service have been set, too. During business hours,
all in-coming calls are answered-nothing rolls to voicemail. "When
people call about their finances, they are concerned and want to talk
to a person, not a recording. That may not always be best from a
time-management standpoint, but it is good service," McCabe says.
Clients can always access near-real-time account information in a secure, encrypted area of WNA's Web site, www.wna-inv.com. Performance numbers, asset allocation and much more are refreshed by 10 a.m. each Monday when data reflecting the previous week's close is uploaded from Portfolio Center (formerly Centerpiece), the portfolio management software. WNA's current site was built in 2005 with the help of Schwab, its primary custodian, which makes the uploading process "a lot easier," Westrick says.
Like other small shops, leveraging technology is a primary business
challenge for WNA. Migrating to Junxure 18 months ago improved
communications between employees, among other things. Looking ahead,
the new conference room will be outfitted with wireless technology and
a plasma screen on the wall, to facilitate client presentations and for
in-house education, such as watching Webcasts.
Coming next: imaging of client documents such as tax and estate
documents, so they can be placed on the Web site for easy access by
clients. "We're always trying to develop new service capabilities,"
Westrick says. Indeed, maintaining superior service while WNA grows is
another major challenge he and McCabe know they face as successful
independent advisors. "But that's one reason we hired another planner,"
Westrick says, "and why we're renovating our offices."