Assets continue to balloon, even as the debate about performance continues to bubble.
Socially responsible investing can mean different
things to different people, having grown over the past few decades into
an investment philosophy that can encompass religion, politics and
environmental concerns.
Yet one thing about SRI does seem clear: There is a thriving demand for it among individual investors.
Nearly 10% of all professionally managed investments
are SRI funds, according to a 2005 report by the Social Investment
Forum. The same report found that SRI investment assets grew 260%
between 1995 and 2005, from $639 million to $2.29 trillion, and that
mainstream money managers have been increasingly incorporating social
and environmental screening into their holding selection process.
The extent to which SRI investing has grown since
2005 will be addressed by the Social Investment Forum at the end of
this year, when it conducts its biennial SRI trend report. Anecdotally,
however, advisors and managers say they continue to see a growing
interest among investors in making their social, political and
religious beliefs a part of their overall investment strategy.
Observers say the number of socially responsible
investors continues to grow, particularly those interested in
investment products tied to issues dealing with the environment and
global warming and religion-based SRI funds. More SRI funds are also
appearing in the form of ETFs, and it is becoming more common to find
SRI funds among the selections available to workers in their
employee-sponsored defined contribution plans.
Looked at in another way, socially responsible
investing is another byproduct of investments moving from the
professional realm into mainstream America as a result of the shift to
defined contribution plans. Advisors say that socially responsible
investing isĀ an effort by their clients to personalize an
investment process that has traditionally been grounded in logic and
quantitative analysis.
"As baby boomers are aging, they are coming back to
their roots a little bit and there is, after making money, the thought
of, now what do we do and what kind of footprint are we leaving," says
Lisa Kirchenbauer, president of Kirchenbauer Financial Management and
Consulting in Arlington, Va. Kirchenbauer, who has been helping clients
select SRI funds for years, said another reason investors are more apt
to put money into an SRI investment is that these products now
encompass a broader range of interests. "I think these days many people
realize that SRI just isn't alcohol, weapons and nuclear energy," she
says.
Just as advisors have expanded the scope of their
profession beyond investment management to helping clients achieve
their life goals and aspirations, more investors are making an effort
to ensure that their investments are in tune with their deeply held
beliefs, even if it costs them some performance, advisors say.
David Freeman-Woolpert, who holds about half of his
clients' $40 million in assets in SRI-related investments, says he
tries to size up a client's stand on SRI investing early on. "I raise
the question with every client," he says.
Some maintain a wall between their beliefs and their
investments and ask for the best fund available, he says. Some will
compromise between their beliefs and the way they take action on those
beliefs, often by putting assets into an SRI product only if its
performance records will help them achieve their goals.
Most often, however, clients will make SRI a
priority-which may be related to the fact that, with his business in
the state capital of New Hampshire, he has a large percentage of civil
service workers as clients. "I get a lot of people who are doing the
work they do because of the impact they can make. To put money into
something that goes against the grain just seems to be against what
they stand for in their professions," says Freeman-Woolpert, an
LPL-affiliated advisor who is the owner of Altus Investment Group in
Concord, N.H.
Multiple Meanings
In today's investment market, calling something
"SRI" isn't enough, says David Kathman, mutual fund analyst with
Morningstar Inc. "It all depends on how you define SRI," he says.
Perhaps the most distinct groupings within the SRI category are the
religious and the nonreligious funds, he says. Religious funds have
been a fast-growing sector, going from under $500 million to more than
$17 billion in assets in ten years, Kathman says. Catholic, Protestant
and Islamic funds make up the three main divisions in this category.
The largest funds within the religious category are the Ave Maria
Catholic Values Fund, the Presbyterian-based New Covenant funds, the
Southern Baptist Convention Guidestone Funds and the Islamic Amana
Trust growth and income funds, according to Kathman. (See related story
on page 105.)
In recent years, one of the busiest SRI sectors has
been the environmental area, particularly funds that tie into the
global warming issue by investing in clean alternative energy
companies. Although this is not an entirely new area of SRI
activity-given that the New Alternatives Fund has been investing in
renewable energy since 1982-it is an area that has benefited from the
rising prominence of the global warming debate, observers say.
Kirchenbauer says this may be because concern about
the environment cuts across all areas of socially responsible
investing, regardless of where people stand politically or religiously.
"The place where there is an intersection is the environment," she says.
Recent environmental SRI fund launches include the
Guinness Atkinson Alternative Energy Fund and the Global Warming
Prevention Equity Fund. The WilderShares Progressive Energy Portfolio
and the PowerShares Cleantech Portfolio, both index-based, are ETFs
recently launched by PowerShares. Before those, PowerShares launched
the WilderHill Clean Energy Portfolio in March 2005, which has since
grown to about $950 million in assets, and launched the Water Resources
Portfolio in December 2005, which has more than $1 billion in assets.
PowerShares CEO Bruce Bond says the company has also
submitted filings to the SEC for the launch of Global Water and Global
Clean Energy ETFs. Bond says he feels that specialized SRI funds, such
as the four ETFs launched by PowerShares, are more easily
understandable to the investment community. "When you call yourself an
SRI fund and that's all you do, it's difficult for a person to
understand what that really means," he says. "We want something that is
very clear to people so they clearly understand what it is they are
investing in."
In another indication of the attention environmental
and energy issues are getting, Calvert Investments has filed papers
with the SEC to start its own alternative energy fund this year. The
fund, called Calvert Global Alternative Energy Fund, will seek to
invest in companies that "demonstrate leadership in providing solutions
to the climate change crisis through renewable energy and other
alternative environmental technologies," according to the filing.
Calvert officials would not comment on the new fund
filing, but they noted that the company has been active on the
environment and is a participant in the Carbon Disclosure Project, a
global effort to compel the world's largest companies to disclose their
greenhouse gas emission levels.
"If there's any trend in socially responsible investing, it's the
ever-sharpening focus over the last couple of years on climate change
as something that we concentrate on, not only in our research, but also
in our policy and advocacy work," says Bennett Freeman, Calvert's
senior vice president for social research and policy.
SRI Performance
One of the common knocks against SRI funds is that
investors can expect to take a performance hit. The lower performance,
the critics say, is a penalty investors should expect to pay for
following their emotions, rather than pure asset allocation, for
selecting investments.
There is, however, much debate over this point.
Kathman of Morningstar, for example, argues that studies into the
performance of SRI funds are inconclusive, and that the question of
whether they are, on average, underperformers is debatable. Some
advisors argue that the performances of SRI funds should be considered
just like those of any other portfolios-that the analysis depends on
the fund, its investment style and the market conditions being looked
at. Freeman-Woolpert of Altus Investment Group says, for example, that
while the Calvert Social Investment Equity Fund-the company's flagship
SRI fund-has underperformed the market over the past ten years, the
Calvert Large Cap Growth Fund has outperformed the S&P 500 over the
same period. Calvert's international and long-term bond funds have also
outperformed their peer groups, he adds. "I don't invest in the average
SRI fund, so I don't worry about average performance," he says.
But SRI funds do have shared characteristics that
can lead to down times. The typical SRI screen, for example, will
usually kick out oil and gas companies, leaving a fund underrepresented
in energy. With the energy sector being a top performer during the past
several years, this exclusion has hurt the bottom-line performance of
many SRI funds. It was enough of a blow that the iconic Domini Social
Equity Fund last year shifted from a passive index to an active
management style of investing to avoid a similar fate in the future.
Janet Hoffman, who covers socially responsible
investing for the investment committee of Bingham, Osborn &
Scarborough wealth managers in San Francisco, says that for a firm like
hers, which is focused on indexing and value, SRI funds can be a bad
mix. This is partly due to the "growth" nature of SRI funds, which have
a tendency to be overweight in technology, but also because of high
turnover, loads and relatively high expense ratios. As a result, the
firm has limited its use of SRI to six funds. The list includes the
Domini Social Equity Fund, the Pimco Total Return III Institutional
Fund, the Pimco Low Duration III Institutional Fund and the Vanguard
FTSE Social Index Fund, Hoffman says. The list also includes two ETFs,
the iShares KLD Select Social Index and the iShares KLD 400 Social
Index.