Managing growth isn't easy.
In this era of large financial advisory firms
seeking only to get larger, one couldn't find a better model of growth
than the 15-year run of McLean, Va.-based Sullivan, Bruyette, Speros
& Blayney (SBSB).
Greg Sullivan opened the doors of his Northern Virginia practice in
January 1991. He knew Eleanor Blayney as a local planner with three
years under her belt; Jim Bruyette he'd worked with at Ernst &
Whinney in the '80s. Peter Speros was one of those
professional-athlete-turned-financial advisors not uncommon in the
Washington, D.C., area.
In looking at SBSB's recent achievements-most
notable of which is its sale to Harris Bank of Chicago in 2003-it helps
to review briefly the history of the firm. "In 1991," says Speros, "our
five-year goal had been to get to $100 million under management, but we
got there in only three years." SBSB's assets under management now
stand at $1.6 billion, a persistent growth rate of approximately 26% a
year for 15 years. Not that the focus should be on the assets this or
any other firm manages; those are merely a yardstick with which to
measure SBSB's success in latching onto a superior business model and
working it to the extraordinary benefit of its clients, employees and
partners.
Ingredients To Success
The ingredients to SBSB's success have been threefold: teamwork, standardization and luck.
Teamwork.
"One factor inhibiting the growth of many advisory firms is that the
partners tend to be very protective of clients and only share resources
and support services," believes Sullivan. "It doesn't take long for
these business models to prove they aren't scalable." A simple but
profound truth? Yes, and a key component in SBSB's growth.
From the start, SBSB's avoided internal territorial
turf wars and treated clients as belonging to the firm, not individual
partners. "When we find what Eleanor calls a 'blueberry patch' of good
clients, we all come in to harvest it," says Sullivan. What he
describes is as much an attitude as a methodology-an attitude of having
a truly collective venture, not a collection of fiefdoms under one
roof. And it requires trust. "We prospered because we trust each other
to do what's right for each of us and for the company, and we respect
each other's skills and capabilities."
Teamwork also means bringing other peoples'
expertise to bear on a new client. Blayney is generally deferred to on
investment management issues, while Speros gets the call on risk
management questions. "The focus is always on the client and what group
of employees can best meet his or her needs. We do have set teams, but
each managing director can choose how to structure a team for a given
client." (In SBSB lingo, a partner is a managing director, but a
managing director isn't necessarily a partner).
Sullivan calls this "open architecture." "I work with my own team 80%
of the time; other times I'll bring other people onto the team. Or, if
I get a client from a particular company, I might put that client with
a team that's already working with clients from the same company."
Bottom line is that the sum is greater than its
parts. Partners who fail to work collectively don't realize the scale
and the growth of firms whose partners suppress their appetite for
individual stardom.
Standardization.
Successful firms understand the basic truth that you customize what the
client holds dear while standardizing essential but unseen processes.
Take investment management. SBSB has a policy of how
a portfolio should be set up and a philosophy of how it should be
managed. "We want managing directors to be able to make unique
decisions for a client, but do so within the guidelines we've set,"
says Sullivan.
Up front, clients get the focused attention of a
managing director and his or her team. On the back end, though, SBSB is
like a manufacturing plant, doing everything for the client with
support from Charles Schwab. The proof of its scalability? "We have the
same three-person team now with $1.6 billion AUM as we did with $800
million," says Sullivan. "We're at 40 employees now and believe it will
take only 50% more employees to double our AUM over the next three
years."
SBSB applies the same philosophy to financial
planning, using Naviplan reports that are standardized as to what they
contain and how they are bound and presented. Their tax work (yes, with
two CPAs' names on the door, the firm does tax returns) is similarly
standardized, using Pro Systems software, several employees to do data
input and several more to review the returns on the back end.
"We've also committed to writing up job descriptions
and publishing a handbook to guide employees in doing financial
planning and tax return preparation." Borrowing a theme from Good to
Great by Jim Collins, SBSB gets the right people doing the right things
for the right clients. "We've spent nine months building a clear career
path for our staff, so they know what their job is, how they'll get
promoted and what pay ranges and bonuses they can expect, all the way
from early entry to managing director."
Perhaps more significant, though, is the managing
directors' realization that they were too close to the firm's
processes. "We have lots of great ideas at the policy-making level,"
Sullivan says, "but we couldn't let partners remain involved in
day-to-day goings on. We needed key people other than ourselves to take
charge of operations, so we appointed operations managers for each of
our key areas: portfolios, financial planning, tax returns, technology
and human resources." All operations managers report weekly to a
committee made up of Sullivan, Bruyette and Speros.
"We've also created a new position called
'Experience Manager,' a person who focuses on improving the client and
employee service. It's her job to make sure everyone's feeling valued
within the firm. If she knows of any issues she brings them to us, the
Operating Committee." Which returns us to the issue of trust. An
employee could easily see the Experience Manager as a company spy but,
says Sullivan, the firm's employees value this manager and trust her to
keep things in confidence while, at the same time, working to get
problems ironed out.
Luck. Are
teamwork and standardization the keys to success? Not without a little
luck, says Sullivan. "We got lucky landing multiple clients from AOL
(which opened a 220,000-square-foot facility in northern Virginia in
1999) and Microsoft people when those businesses were hot. Their people
needed what we offered."
Getting Noticed
With a solid framework of teams, standards and luck,
it's not surprising that SBSB caught the eye of Harris Bank. Cecily
Mistarz, executive vice president of Harris Private Bank, says several
key characteristics attracted Harris to SBSB, and would attract them to
another acquisition. "They led with a strong financial planning
approach supported by excellent planning professionals and
relationships managers. This was evident to us in their clients'
satisfaction with their services, the referrals they received from
their clients-their strong client relationships, in general. Their
trusted advisor approach, the fact they truly care about their
employees and their clients, was the right cultural fit for us,"
Mistarz explains.
The feeling was mutual, says Jim Bruyette. "Harris
has been an extremely ethical group to deal with, living up to every
promise its people have made. Further, many of these deals are
done because the buyer wants to impose its method of doing business
onto the company it's acquired. This was different because Harris
was looking to import financial planning expertise and the bank has
encouraged us to continue doing business as we see fit."
The bank would entertain other acquisition
candidates, Mistarz says, but hasn't yet found what it's looking for.
She says, "We're very selective. We want a firm with the same
characteristics as Sullivan Bruyette but, so far, it's been impossible
to replicate."
"We weren't looking to sell when we were approached
by Harris," Sullivan says. SBSB had frequent suitors, and Sullivan and
his partners would politely listen to their pitches, but nothing would
come of them. When Harris said it would take a hands-off approach to
SBSB, though, they listened more closely.
The sit-down with Harris forced Sullivan and his
partners to think hard about what they wanted. "We decided we needed
financial security, including employment contracts, and we wanted to
know our clients would be taken care of whether or not we were
involved."
"When we next met, we each put our numbers on the
table to see how close we were." They decided to keep talking, which
began what Sullivan describes as "the grueling process" of having a
large company come into your office and turn over every piece of paper,
looking for risk and liability exposure. The most notable aspect of the
negotiations? "They never stopped. The day before the signing, we were
still negotiating issues."
The Deal
What did they get-the bottom line, the big number?
Blayney will say only that it was a multimillion dollar sale.
Unconfirmed reports say it was just below the $15 million mark. "It
would be difficult to reduce the selling price to one number, as there
were many aspects to the deal, such as employees' compensation, tax
angles, etc," Blayney explains.
"We didn't want to do it strictly on an earn-out
basis," says Sullivan. "We wanted guaranteed payments, we wanted to
participate in upside growth, and we wanted employment contracts long
enough to keep us involved without feeling tied in." In 2003, they
started out with three-year contracts and recently renegotiated five
more years.
Will employees stay on at the end of the newly
negotiated five-year contract? "That's our hope," says Sullivan "If new
leadership were to come on board at that time, our key people would
hang in there. The new leadership might, in fact, come from our own
managing directors." SBSB expects to open up more managing director
slots, as many as one per year for the next three years.
The Aftermath
Commenting on their post-sale interaction with
Harris, Blayney says, "Mostly, it has been positive, as they've
shared with us their (personnel) search capabilities, our accounting is
done centrally, and we now have a better emergency preparedness plan."
"Harris has audit committees that need to come in
and look at our business, but it's helpful; we run a better business
because of it," says Sullivan. On a slightly more cynical note, he
adds, "The larger organization is trying to figure out if you know what
you're doing. You need to suck it up and just get through it."
The best way to deal with the minor intrusions,
Sullivan discovered, was to let everyone in SBSB do their own thing
while he and Bruyette dealt with the bank. "We keep our employees
insulated and focused on client service."
"Our employees like the idea of more formalized
reviews and compensation, and they find comfort in the big corporate
infrastructure," says Blayney. "Certainly Greg and Jim are consummate
businessmen, but we began in a conference room meeting with clients and
that's what we like to do; writing a human resources manual wasn't
something we worried about. So there are times now when all of us feel
the weight of a bank bureaucracy, but we knew that was part of the
deal. The upside is it shifts some risk away from us."
Perhaps the sign of a smooth transition is the fact
that the clients hardly noticed. "They're not particularly aware of the
change even though they know it took place," says Blayney. She says the
clients are getting better service in a number of ways, like investment
research and product selection.
Surprisingly, many clients were unfamiliar with the
bank's name. However, most did know of its parent, the Bank of Montreal.
Lessons
Sullivan says the most important business lesson he
learned was the confirmation of their long-held belief that if they ran
the practice as if it were always for sale, then opportunity would meet
preparation. "When our opportunity came along, we were prepared," he
says.
Was there an important life lesson in this
experience, as well? "I took home the idea of maybe selling the
business, and my son, a high school sophomore at the time, said, "Oh, I
thought some day I might work in your business with you." My response
was, "David, some day you should own a business, but it should be your
own and not mine." I learned that family members have a vested interest
in your business, too.
Sullivan's biggest surprise? "How hard all of my
partners worked after the sale. Each of them has been thoroughly
committed to making this transaction a success. Once you sell the
business, you don't have to do that. We already had our financial
guarantees, so it was really refreshing to know everyone was still
committed to the business and to our clients."
Do Sullivan and his original partners miss working
for themselves? "We don't own all the profits at end of day, but we
still have a lot of skin in this game."
"The only downside I have found," says Bruyette, "is
that we're now part of an organization with deep pockets and must play
strictly by the rules. As a smaller, entrepreneurial company, you try
to remain flexible and avoid having cumbersome policies and procedures;
now that's unavoidable to some extent."
Perhaps most important, says Sullivan, is the legacy
they will create. "You see leadership coming up from your employee
ranks and realize you're a steward of something. Everything you've
worked for is to be passed on. Maybe that's been done from a legal
standpoint, but we're still doing it in an emotional and professional
sense. It's just like raising kids. You want them to grow up and leave
home."
David J. Drucker, M.B.A., CFP, an
independent financial advisor since 1981, now writes, speaks, and
consults with other advisors as president of Drucker Knowledge Systems.
Visit his practice management portal, Practice Lifecycle, at
www.practicelifecycle.com, and Virtual Office News, a practice
management and technology newsletter for financial advisors, at
www.virtualofficenews.com.